This discussion clarifies whether income can be declared under Section 44AD or 44ADA when Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) has been levied under Section 194J(b). The key takeaway is that the TDS section doesn't determine the applicable presumptive scheme; rather, the nature of the client's actual activity does. Section 44ADA is exclusively for specific professions listed in Section 44AA(1), while Section 44AD is available for other business activities not falling under the excluded categories.
31 December 2025
If tds has been deducted under section 194J(b) whether the ITR can be filed by showing income under section 44AD or under section 44ADA ?
14 November 2026
The TDS section does not decide which presumptive scheme applies. The nature of the activity does.
• Sec 44ADA applies only to professions listed in Sec 44AA(1) or notified under it: legal, medical, engineering, architecture, accountancy, technical consultancy, interior decoration, authorised representative, film artist, company secretary and information technology. • If the client's activity is one of these, use 44ADA (50% deemed income; receipts up to Rs 75 lakh with cash within 5%). • If the activity is not a listed profession (e.g. editing, coaching, event anchoring), Sec 44AD can be used (6%/8% of receipts), since 44AD excludes only the listed professions, commission/brokerage and agency business. • The deductor's choice of Sec 194J(b) ("professional services") is not binding on the payee. It may even be inaccurate where the activity is not a listed profession.
In the ITR • Match total receipts with AIS (194J entries). Claim the full TDS whatever section it was deducted under. • Choose the business code that reflects the actual activity. • Keep the engagement letter describing the work, in case the AO questions the choice. • From tax year 2026-27, both schemes are in Sec 58 of the Income-tax Act, 2025.