I want to discuss a crucial issue that has been significantly contributing to the rise of defaulted companies, particularly among listed companies. This issue stems from certain lapses in Section 186(2) of the Companies Act, 2013, which governs loans and investments made by companies.
Understanding Section 186
As per Section 186(2) of the Companies Act, 2013:No company shall, directly or indirectly-(a) Give any loan to any person or other body corporate;(b) Give any guarantee or provide security in connection with a loan to any other body corporate or person; and(c) Acquire by way of subscription, purchase, or otherwise, the securities of any other body corporate,in excess of 60% of its paid-up share capital, free reserves, and securities premium account or 100% of its free reserves and securities premium account, whichever is higher.
Intended Objective vs. Ground Reality:The intention behind this law is to regulate corporate investments and loans to ensure financial stability. However, in practice, its application has led to companies defaulting on loans. The core issue lies in where the money for these investments is coming from.
The Key Lapse in Section 186
- The law permits investments up to 60% of net worth or 100% of free reserves. However, companies rarely maintain cash or cash equivalents up to these limits.
- So, where do they get funds to invest in other companies? They divert working capital loans from banks, which are meant for regular business operations.
- This misuse of borrowed funds weakens financial health, leading to companies becoming sick and eventually defaulting.
The ultimate burden falls on investors and banks, causing financial losses amounting to lakhs of crores of rupees.
Some of the losses to the banks and investors
1) 60 Listed companies disclosed debt default of Rs 75,000 Cr
2) 49 Listed companies disclosed debt default of Rs 69,140 Cr
3) 8 Listed companies have defaulted for 50.93US$ Billion equal to Rs 4.32 Lakh Cr
4) 2263 Listed companies have defaulted for Rs 1.96 Lakh Cr
5) 50 wilful Defaulted companies owe Rs 87,925 Cr to Banks
7) 88 Listed companies have been referred for liquidation as per the NSE website.
8) The list of wilful defaulters as of 30th June 2024 spans 1517 pages.
The Need for Reform
Given the widespread misuse of Section 186, we must act decisively:
1. Amend the Act to restrict companies from using working capital loans for intercorporate investments or loans.
2. Introduce stringent monitoring mechanisms to track the source of funds used for investments.
Conclusion
The lapses in Section 186 of the Companies Act, 2013, have been exploited, resulting in huge financial distress for stakeholders. Addressing this issue is critical to safeguarding India's corporate and banking ecosystem.
CAclubindia
