Direct tax ca final best book

Final 9720 views 20 replies

Back in the Game

1273 Points Joined February 2012

I want book buy a Book of direct Taxes CA Final.

i ve gone through this Forum & opinion of different people yet unable to conclude which is the best book.

i ve Following options

1)Vinod Gupta

2)TN manoharan

3)Dr Girish Ahujha

4)Vinod Singhania

All these are renowned authors

i want a book which will help me give practical insights into the subject,more than passing i want to satisfied with Every aspect of this paper in a Conceptual manner.

I would like the esteemed members of this forum to Guide me regarding as to which is the best for direct taxes & why tat particular book should be selected.

Best Regards

Replies (20)

CA SHUBHAM Mittal

441 Points Joined June 2009

Go for Vindod Gupta .......................

Back in the Game

1273 Points Joined February 2012

Originally posted by : SHUBHAM
	Go for Vindod Gupta .......................

Thanks for ur reply Shubham but if u r referring a book kindly give me the reasons why shall i go for tat particular book.

i ve voluntarily written this post so tat a Clarrity is drawn which book could be best Advisable & more imporatntly WHY?unlike a Flat opinion given in most of the posts in this Forum regarding best book.

So pls back with reasons with ur posts.

CA SHUBHAM Mittal

441 Points Joined June 2009

Check ur PM.

krishan agrawal

student

324 Points Joined December 2011

T n manorahan is good as it is simple easy and can be studied one day before exam . you can refer vg gupta modules if your attempt is in nov.it is too lenghthy.

charanteja.nsr

ACMA and BCOM

818 Points Joined April 2009

tn manoharan ...

CA, CS Kavit S Shah

Professional

211 Points Joined August 2009

Vinod Gupta is the best book from the practical as well as conceptual point of view.

Gaurav

ca student

748 Points Joined March 2009

t n manoharan

chandra

student

528 Points Joined January 2009

For more than exam oriented knowledge and to be satisfied with all aspects of the subjecct, suggest you study all those books. Best of Luck.

chirag

student

186 Points Joined November 2008

one and only VINOD GUPTA

CA.ViVeK M ACA

ACCOUNTS DEPARTMENT

28544 Points Joined November 2008

TN Manoharan is a easy book to learn concepts and Girish Ahuja is a standard Book.. You can opt any one of these

ganesh

Student CA IPC / IPCC

25 Points Joined March 2007

TRY FIRST LESSON ON DIRECT TAXES BY DIVAKAR VIJAYASARATHY. IT CONTAINS HOW MUCH TIME TO BE DEVOTED TO EVERY TOPIC.

CA Madhvi

...Blissful...

1658 Points Joined November 2007

vinod gupta..i scored 73 in dt..simply superb book!!

CA Revati Galgali

B.com ACA DipIFR(ACCA) CS(Exe)

1049 Points Joined November 2011

Padhuka

Budding Professional

B.Com CA & CS FINAL

1686 Points Joined October 2008

All the authors mentioned are very renowned and the books authored are no less but when it comes to in depth understanding and analysis of the subject, VK Singhania's book scores above all. I studied it for PCC and am currently studying from it for the Final and I find it a boon for self studying.

The facts presented are very much in depth and detailed and a number of references to case laws have been given. The language is genuinely professional and there are almost no errors in the book (errors,as far as my study is concerned).

What might trouble you is the small fonts and the clutterdness (to some extent) in the book, but I think that should not be an issue if the book is professionally genuine..

Hope you will find the post useful.

Regards