Raj Jaggi
Quick Summary
When a Deleted Rule Still Haunts Refund Files GST refund disputes often appear technical, involving forms, circulars, notifications, export conditions, formula restrictions and procedural objections. Yet behind these technical details, the real issue is often simpler. Can the Department continue to
Daily Limit Reached
You have reached your daily limit of 2 Free Articles
Subscribe to CCI PRO for unlimited access
Why Upgrade to CCI PRO?
- No Ads
- WhatsApp Broadcasts
- Daily E-Newsletter
- Unlimited Articles Access
BEST VALUE
2 YEAR PLAN
3,499
(Inclusive of GST)
1 YEAR PLAN
1,999
(Inclusive of GST)
View all CCI PRO benfits
Already a PRO member? Login here for an ad-free experience.
FAQ :
No, if the rule has been omitted from the law and the omission notification does not include a saving clause to preserve its application to pending matters, the department cannot use that deleted rule to deny a live GST refund claim.
A saving clause is a provision in a notification that explicitly states that an omitted or repealed rule will continue to apply to certain pending proceedings, notices, or liabilities.
The Gujarat High Court ruled that if a rule like 89(4B) or 96(10) is omitted without a saving clause, it cannot be used to deny a refund claim that was still pending at the time of omission. The claim must be processed under the law as it stands after the omission.
No, the ruling applies to matters that are still 'pending' and not 'past and closed'. A matter is considered past and closed if it has reached finality, such as when the time for appeal has expired and no challenge is ongoing.
It's important because export refunds represent blocked working capital. This ruling ensures that exporters are not unfairly denied refunds based on rules that no longer exist, providing greater certainty in the zero-rating of exports.
The practical test involves checking if the refund was denied under an omitted rule (like 89(4B) or 96(10)), if the matter was pending when the rule was omitted, if there was a saving clause, and if the department has any other valid grounds for denial besides the omitted rule.
CAclubindia
