CA Aman Rajput
As India marks its 75th year as a Republic, it's opportune to reflect on the transformative journey of its economy from a struggling, third-world nation to the world's sixth-largest economy. Against the backdrop of global economic challenges exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic and geopolitical tensions, India's GDP stands resilient, growing at a promising 6.1%. This growth is attributed to strategic economic policies, active digitalization initiatives, and pivotal events like demonetization.
Demonetization, a game-changing move in 2016, involved the withdrawal of INR 500 and INR 1,000 notes, replacing them with new INR 500 and INR 2,000 denominations. The rationale behind this bold step was to curb black money, promote cashless transactions, and combat illegal activities funded by counterfeit currency.
In 2023, another significant development unfolded – the withdrawal of the INR 2,000 note. While not a complete demonetization, this move stirred public concern and raised questions about its impact on the economy. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) reported that around 97.26% of the withdrawn notes have been returned, leaving approximately INR 9760 crores still in circulation.
The decision to withdraw the INR 2,000 note was driven by various factors. The note's introduction in 2016 aimed to address the cash vacuum created by demonetization. However, over time, it became apparent that this high-denomination note facilitated illicit activities, prompting its withdrawal. Approximately 89% of these notes were issued before March 2017, and their value sharply declined from INR 6.73 lakh crores in March 2018 to INR 3.62 lakh crores by March 2023.
The withdrawal process, though causing initial unease, has been notably seamless. The extended legal tender status for the INR 2,000 note provided the public with ample time for deposits or exchanges, minimizing panic. Banks are vigilant in monitoring specific accounts to prevent fraudulent deposits, and income tax regulations impose scrutiny on large cash deposits.
Critics argue that the recall may disrupt sectors reliant on cash transactions, but proponents emphasize its positive impact. The removal of the INR 2,000 note from circulation disrupts illicit activities, encourages deposits, and enhances liquidity in the banking system.
The recall's economic benefits include windfall gains for banks, contributing to the Current and Savings Account Ratio (CASA) and potentially leading to lower lending rates. Mutual funds and direct tax collections may also see positive effects. However, challenges include potential inconveniences for cash-oriented sectors and the need for careful management to prevent misuse of the withdrawal process.
The decision to recall the INR 2,000 note aligns with India's broader push towards a cashless economy. Digitalization efforts, such as Aadhar and UPI, coupled with demonetization and note withdrawal, reflect the government's commitment to transparency, accountability, and financial inclusion.
In the judicial review of demonetization in 2016, the Supreme Court upheld the government's decision, asserting its economic policy immunity from judicial reversal. The verdict highlighted the reasonable connection between the government and the RBI in implementing demonetization.
As India looks ahead, challenges persist, including sluggish private-sector investments, the need for rural consumption revival, and addressing the issue of insufficient quality jobs. Balancing policy measures and leveraging India's demographic advantage will be crucial for sustained economic growth.
In conclusion, the journey of India's economy at 75 is marked by resilience, growth, and transformative policy decisions. Demonetization and the recent withdrawal of the INR 2,000 note, though met with challenges, underscore the government's commitment to fostering a transparent, digitized, and inclusive economic landscape. As India navigates the complexities of its economic future, a comprehensive and balanced approach will be pivotal in realizing the promise of a bright and sustainable tomorrow.
Source: Own research and various articles at TOI
CAclubindia
