Mega Offer Avail 65% Off in CA IPCC and 50% Off in all CA CS CMA subjects.Coupon- IPCEXAM65 & EXAM50. Call: 088803-20003

CA Final Online Classes
CA Classes

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Types of Nuisances and their Remedies

CS Deepak Pratap Singh 
on 03 December 2020

LinkedIn


We are living in a modern world, where some degree of nuisance is tolerable relating to noise, dust, pollution, smell, smoke, and escape of effluents, etc. We are daily facing various types of nuisances and we ignore to some extent.

A nuisance may come from your neighbors, your locality, and your state, or even from various other authorities.

The term "Nuisance" is made of the French word "nuire" and Latin word "nocere" or "nocumentum", which in a legal sense means "annoyance" or "harm".

Nuisance defined in free dictionary; - One that is inconvenient, annoying or vexatious and use of property or course of conduct that interferes with the legal rights of others by causing damage, annoyance, or inconvenience.

A person, thing, or situation that is annoying or that causes troubles or problems.

Wikipedia defines; nuisance as a common-law tort. It means that which causes offense, annoyance, trouble, or injury. It can be either public or private.

"an act not warranted by law, or an omission to discharge a legal duty, which act or omission obstructs or causes inconveniences or damage to the public."

Now let us suppose we are living in a civilized society in which all are living together with peace and harmony. If one of your neighbors starts behaving rudely, produces noise, throws garbage in the society, not ready to follow the rules of the society, and accommodates some anti-social person in his/her residence. All these acts of your neighbor which causes annoyance harm to you and the society is a type of nuisance.

Types of Nuisances and their Remedies

Nuisance has been defined under two categories;

  1. Public Nuisance, and
  2. Private Nuisance

PUBLIC NUISANCE

If any act of a person annoys a large number of persons or class of persons, it is called "Public Nuisance".

A Public Nuisance is an unreasonable interference with the public rights to the property. Any act which affects the safety, health, and right to live in peace of the people is a nuisance. Suppose someone has blocked the highway, due to which the public is unable to use that facility. It is a Public Nuisance that affects a large number of public.

Section 268, India Penal Code, 1860 provides that; "a person is guilty of public nuisance who does any act, or is guilty of an illegal omission, which causes any common injury, danger or annoyance to the public or the people in general who dwell or occupy the property in the vicinity or which must necessarily cause injury, obstruction, danger or annoyance to persons who may have occasion to use any public right."

Note: if any person is injured due to an act of another person in the nature of Public Nuisance, he/she can sue the person for damages as a Private nuisance.

As decided in the case of Soltan v. De Held (1851) 2sim RS 133, De Held, was the priest of a Church. Throughout the day the bell of the Church was ringing and producing sound, which affects the people living in the vicinity of the Church. The plaintiff was the most affected person since his house was near the Church. The Court in this case decided that it was a type of Public Nuisance and the plaintiff was entitled to injection.

Dr. Ram Raj Singh. Babu Lal, AIR, 1982 ALL285; the defendants had installed a brick grinding machine on his plot and the plaintiff was a doctor and have a clinic adjoining the plot of the defendant. Due to brick grinding the adjacent environment had been polluted with the red brick materials and the same was visible on the dress of doctors, which affects the health of the persons residing in the vicinity of the clinic. The plaintiff brought a suit against the defendant for damages and got an injection order from the Court on the basis of Public Nuisance.

PRIVATE NUISANCE

If the freedom or property of an individual is affected due to any act of another person, it is a private nuisance.

"Lord Winfield" defined it as; unlawful interference with a person’s use or enjoyment of land, or some right over, or in connection with it, which causes damage to the persons’ property or safety.

The interference will be unwarranted, which causes damages to the plaintiff and such interferences are termed as undue or unreasonable. Any interference, which exceeds limited uses permitted in any society, is undue or unreasonable.

Note: the interference must be continuous or repetitive.

As decided in the case of Radhey Shyam v. Gur Prasad, AIR 1978 ALL 86; Gur Prasad brought a case before the Court and got an injection by claiming that the flour mill, which was going to be installed in the premises by the defendant in which he resides, will cause serious health issue and noise, so he can lose his peace on account of the rattling noise of the flour mill. The Court observed the act of the defendant as a Private nuisance and issued an order for restraining the installation of a flour mill on the premises.

Usha Ben v.Bhagya Laxmi Chitra Mandir, AIR 1978(Guj) 13(1977) GLR 424; in this case Usah Ben brought the case before the Court and demand complete ban on screening the film in the theatre, because in the film three deities Laxmi, Parvati and Saraswati were shown a jealous with each other. This episode hurt the Usha Ben very much. The Court has decided that the film did not hurt any religious feeling and not an actionable wrong. Usha Ben if found it hurting, then she can decide not to see the film.

Note: if a person is very sensitive for a particular thing but for others that thing is very normal, then it is not a nuisance.

If a lawful act is done by defendant with a wrong intention or malice, it is a nuisance.

A private nuisance can be done either (1) injury to property or (2) injury to the health or comfort of an occupier of land. If property gets damaged due to unreasonable inference then it is an actionable nuisance.

Suppose the plants and trees in the garden of your neighbour have been damaged due to fumes emitted from your house or factory. Then it is an actionable nuisance.

 

Actions for private nuisance also lie for interference with easement, profits-a-pendre and certain rights which are generally called as "natural rights". It is inherent in the ownership to support of one’s land by one’s neighbor’s land.

Stroyean v. Knowls, (1861) 6 H & N 454; the defendants were carrying on mining operations which caused the plaintiff’s land to subside. In consequence it damages the factory of the plaintiff. The court found that the weight of the building did not contribute to the causing of the subsidence. The defendant was held liable.

Section 34 of Indian Easement Act says- "the removable of the means of support to which dominant owner is entitled does not give rise to a right to recover compensation, unless and until substantial damage is actually sustained."

Section 25 of the Limitation Act, 1963 says- right of easement to light, air, way, water course, use of water etc., can be acquired by prescription if the right has been peaceably enjoyed as an easement and as of right without interruption and for twenty years.

Section 33 of the Indian Easement Act, enables and person to bring an action against the defendant if there is a substantial infringement of an easement of light, air, water, water to use etc.

It is necessary to prove actual damage, when cause of nuisance arises. In case of public nuisance, the action is brought against the defendant, when the plaintiff proves special damage to him. But when the nuisance is related to other than physical damage to property, damage is presumed by law without imposing upon the plaintiff the difficult task of proving it or providing evidence.

 

DEFENCES AVAILABLE

Prescription: it is a special defense and the right to continue a private nuisance may be acquired as an easement by prescription. The easement should be enjoyed peacefully and openly. This type of nuisance can be enjoyed for a period of 20 years and after that, it will be legalized.

Statutory Authority; if a statute has allowed or authorized to do a particular act, all remedies, whether by way of indictment or action, are taken away, provided that every reasonable precaution consistent with the exercise of the statutory power has been taken away.

REMEDIES

Abetment; means removable of nuisance by the person affected, but the removable must be peaceful and life should not be endangered.

Injection; is based on the nature of the nuisance and if the nuisance is such that it is impeding and should be stopped. Then injection is necessary.

Damages; if the plaintiff succeeds in proving that the nuisance caused damages to his property or health, and then the Court may order for payment of compensation for the damages.

Legal Disclaimer

The information/articles & any replies to the comments on this blog are provided purely for informational & educational purposes only& are purely based on the understanding/knowledge of the author. They do not constitute any legal advice or legal opinions. The information/articles & any replies to the comments are intended but not promised or guaranteed to be correct or up-to-date and should in no way be taken /considered as legal advice/opinion. Therefore, the author cannot take any responsibility for the results or any consequences of any attempt to use or adopt any of the information or replies presented in the blog. You are requested /advised not to act on any information/ articles & replies given on comments without consulting any Practicing Professional.


Tags :



Category Corporate Law
Other Articles by -
CS Deepak Pratap Singh 

Report Abuse

LinkedIn



Comments


update