In the ever-evolving landscape of finance and business, auditors find themselves navigating through turbulent seas, facing challenges that are as dynamic as the markets they scrutinize. The present times have ushered in a wave of uncertainties, demanding auditors to not only uphold the pillars of transparency and accountability but also to adapt swiftly to a new set of challenges. In such scenarios, auditors may encounter challenges in comprehending the intricate details of certain highly technical areas. Recognizing the limitations of their own expertise, it becomes essential for auditors to proactively seek external assistance from professionals or experts well-versed in those specific domains. This collaborative approach ensures a thorough and accurate audit process, leveraging specialized knowledge where needed.
The recognition of this challenge led to the formulation of three auditing standards by the ICAI, providing a framework for auditors to rely on external parties effectively. These standards are outlined as follows:
- SA 600 - Using work of another auditor
- SA 610 - Using work of Internal auditor
- SA 620 - Using work of an Auditor's expert
While auditors have the option to seek assistance or delegate specific tasks to other auditors or experts, it's crucial to emphasize that the primary responsibility for forming and expressing an opinion on the financial statement rests with the auditor. The act of relying on the work of others necessitates the auditor's commitment to exercising adequate skill and care throughout the audit process. This ensures a judicious integration of external expertise into the audit while maintaining the auditor's overarching responsibility for the final opinion on the financial statements.
Determining the utilization of another auditor's or expert's work is a critical aspect of audit planning and strategy development.Further, it is imperative to communicate to the management that auditor would be using an Auditor's expert / management expert specifying the areas of the audit for sufficient appropriate audit evidences. It is also important to determine the professional competency and extent of reliance to be placed and competency of the person who would be conducting the assignment / area assigned as determined by the auditor of the company.
The auditor has the right to determined whether complete reliance can be placed on the audit procedures adopted by expert / internal auditor / another auditor or additional procedures needs to be performed by the auditor of the financial statement. For example, in case of SA 600 -Using work of another auditor, the principal auditor may prescribe the materiality of the parent company and the high-risk areas and guide the component auditor to perform certain audit procedures to arrive at the conclusion. In this regard the auditor may specify in his audit report, the areas which have been audited by another auditor and which has been omitted. However, in case of SA 610 - Using work of Internal auditor and SA 620 - Using work of Auditor's expert, the work done by the external parties can only be used as suitable audit evidence after performing suitable audit procedures. The auditor of financial statement however, cannot state in his audit report regarding the reliance of the auditor / expert.
In addition to communicating with the management or those charged with governance (TCWG), it is essential for the auditor of the financial statements to establish clear and comprehensive communication channels with other auditors or experts involved. This communication should explicitly outline the nature, scope, roles, and responsibilities allocated among the different parties engaged in the audit. The resulting agreement serves as a crucial component of the audit evidence, detailing the necessary extent of direction and supervision that the auditor of the financial statements must provide. This proactive approach ensures a cohesive and well-coordinated audit process, enhancing the reliability and effectiveness of the overall audit.
In conclusion, the collaboration between auditors and external parties is pivotal in addressing the dynamic challenges of today's financial landscape. Standards like SA 600, SA 610, and SA 620 provide a framework for this collaboration. Despite the option to seek external assistance, auditors bear the primary responsibility for forming opinions on financial statements. The nuanced approach in determining reliance on external procedures, guided by different standards, highlights the complexity of audit engagements.
CAclubindia
