Regarding 44AD

If a client who is not maintaining his books of accounts and is required to prepare a Balance Sheet by bankers for loan purpose, should he show the same profit as shows in ITR filed u/s 44AD/44ADA/44AE?
Can there be any deviations?
Especially in case of 44AE, in which we show income per truck, say Rs 80000, should he show complete Rs 80000 as profit in P&L?
Replies (5)
Yes, profit should be the same as reported in ITR..Bankers may check profits with ITR
yes I think there is a similar case law in which it was decided that assesse can't show two different profits. a lower one for Income Tax and higher for Bank loan purpose
thank you for the reply
but wouldn't it be very hard and impractical to show the rounded off profit of Rs 80000 as I took in the example,
we have receipts of Rs 807654 from a truck, and we have to show our expenses in such fashion that the resulting profit balances at Rs 80000.
What you are speaking is correct but think yourseld that 44AE is presumptive on the concept that you are not preparing proper books of account then how could you make profit and loss for bank requirements..

still you have to put expenses in order to get desired profit

It is not necessary that the assessee had to declare only the minimum amount in presumptive returns.

In fact he can volantarily declare the minimum amount or the actual amount whichever is higher. The intention of the law is to make the filing easy for the tax payer and that he should not maintain accurate accounts.

But all businessmen/ professionals maintain rough accounts. It is a part of business. In my opinion, at least a rough Profit and loss account & balance sheet should be made before filing returns especially if the clients needs bank loans.

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register