Protest against icai - unite please - Students

Protest against icai - unite please

Page no : 8

ANIL KUMAR (CA.CS FINAL MBA B.COM-H) (91 Points)
Replied 10 August 2014

I want to add that... Providing facilities like revaluation and certified copies is another way of making money. Thats it. revaluation does not include remarking of exams...only checking that totalling is correct. On the other hand while providing certified copies u have to agree that u wil not take any legal action. then wats d use of all this. . further result fluctuation..... sometimes on prime ministers order result goes to 33%.... and sometimes it is only 3-4%... .... No fixed syllabus...no fixed exam pattern....no fixed checking pattern...no fixed result pattern.... all this shows institutes own wish....MONOPOLY....APNI MARGI HAI INKI..... .

Gagan Deep Singh (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (1190 Points)
Replied 10 August 2014

Mere ko to yeh samaj mein nhi ata icai wale isca ke piche q pade hai..hume accountant banana hai engineer nahi

Dev Chandra Yadav ACMA,CGMA (Senior Associate Financial Planning & A) (23 Points)
Replied 10 August 2014

55,ISCA 23 expected 70+,54,59

Dev Chandra Yadav ACMA,CGMA (Senior Associate Financial Planning & A) (23 Points)
Replied 10 August 2014

Seems like ICAI deliberately failed students in ISCA neither awarding any exemptions this attempt . In my friend circle of around 10 no one passed ISCA . Disgusting, Totally unfair...

Dev Chandra Yadav ACMA,CGMA (Senior Associate Financial Planning & A) (23 Points)
Replied 10 August 2014

Despite being easiest paper at Final level. Indeed 10th standard student can score 80+ if fair markings done

Puneet Sharma (Articled Assistant) (56 Points)
Replied 10 August 2014

I also agree with .my expectation in sfm around 80+ but actual marks is 43 This is totally a politics of institute ....... I can go for revaluation but old students r saying there is no scope in revaluation & it is totally a time wastage...please suggest me what can I do.....

tarun (Student CA Final ) (36 Points)
Replied 10 August 2014

I agree with the statement that toppers mark sheet should be uploaded so that we can get an idea of what we have to write

Sajjad Adam Naik (CA ) (111 Points)
Replied 10 August 2014

yeah @ D Singhal, Chandan Bhatia, what do ICAI mean by "critical checking" if you are right you get marks otherwise you dont get, but you can't reduce marks in Practical Questions, one of my friend got 58 marks in Nov 13 in SFM but lost in aggregate,however this time he got 31 marks in SFM. Now this is some bullsh*t.

muralikrishna (student) (19 Points)
Replied 10 August 2014

Yes I am also punished by Icai. We need justice!!!!

RAJU VERMA (ARTICLED ASSISTANT) (39 Points)
Replied 11 August 2014

hey please provide me link for writing to PMO

varun (student) (96 Points)
Replied 11 August 2014

i think now protest is over...actually many ppl got artound 40 so they are confused so they are not here..and some ppl who manage to pass will discourage other..because ........

jake pawn na fate bewai ..ka jane peer parai.....means jab tak khud ke uapar na gujre tab tak dusro ka dukh nahi samjh sakte...this line especially for ..MATHURI and kaNHAIYA..

well i did not purchase the book of DT and IDT and i got more than ISCA...jise maine 25 day lagatar pada...even om the day of costing i read isca... and i got 14..

i am confident that mere marks increase honge...

i just want a suggestion..plz plz plz tell me....

if i did wrong i am punished for 6 month....

if ICAI has done wrong....what legal action i can take against ICAI...after increasing my Number..in isca...

because i have to wait for verification..

for my time loss

for my stress

for my 500RS

for my confusion that whether i will get around 50 or more that 60

plz help me

Jill. (CA-Final Student) (114 Points)
Replied 11 August 2014

Everyone has the same story...

i really fail to understand how they work out all this

they are demotivating their own profession...

Nisha (Student CA Final ) (22 Points)
Replied 11 August 2014

Hello friends,

I am nisha.I again failed this tym.I am very much depressed.I was the ranker student during my academic periods and i have also cleared my CS in first shot. But I dont know why am i failing again and again in CA.My parents and everyone is tonting me as if what kind of student am I?.I am feeling so bad.This is my fifth attempt.I have given my best and have expected exemptions in so many papers but have not got.My parents are not talking to me and treating me so badly.Please help me guyss what to do now because i feel as if i have spoiled my life.

abhilasha jain (article) (188 Points)
Replied 11 August 2014

Originally posted by : Nisha
	Hello friends, I am nisha.I again failed this tym.I am very much depressed.I was the ranker student during my academic periods and i have also cleared my CS in first shot. But I dont know why am i failing again and again in CA.My parents and everyone is tonting me as if what kind of student am I?.I am feeling so bad.This is my fifth attempt.I have given my best and have expected exemptions in so many papers but have not got.My parents are not talking to me and treating me so badly.Please help me guyss what to do now because i feel as if i have spoiled my life.

NISHA , I THINK U MUST APPLY FOR CERTIFIED COPIES OF ALL SUBJECTS AND SHOW YOUR PARENTS WHAT U DID AND HOW MARKS ARE AWARDED BY THEM.

Nisha (Student CA Final ) (22 Points)
Replied 11 August 2014

My parents are not believing me.Now am doing job and only three months are left i dont know how to study.My pparents are not allowing me to give exam but i wouls give so i cant study at home where should i go and study.M very upset by result.