Attention students !!!

Final 7711 views 48 replies

Dear students, I am a CA Final student. It has been my keen observation since last 4 years that today some of (or most of) CAs are abusing their positions to harass and exploit students by the following well designed mental torture methods:


1. Subjecting students to do the personal works beyond a limit and making them servants.

2. Non payment / irregular payment of stipends.

3. Forcing them to work beyond normal working hours.

4. Exercising coercion and threatening them to terminate articleship.

5. Extending their articleship illegally. etc. etc. and much more.


India is a democratic country and as we all know and whether you like my words orr not, there is no one today to raise voice against this exploitation in the name of studies. Students cannot take any action against their principals as it is but natural that if he/she takes any action against his principal, his/her relation with the principal will get highely strained which will ultimately be harmful to the student and as a result of which there are many students in many corners of our country are getting exploited by our honorable members and I have come across cases where the exploitation crosses its limits.


I am strictly against the word "Exploitation". Without writing much about me, I would directly like to write my point which is as under:


If you are suffering from any of the below given mental torture methods by any of the CA in India, then you can contact me right here on CAclubindia. I will give my best in advising you the right course of action considering the case, I will file complaints to the descipline department of ICAI under various clauses and regulations of CA Act for you with/without disclosing your name if you so desire, I will assist you in moving to the high courts against your boss and flow my own money for the litigations against members considering the seriousness of the case:


1. If there are dummy articles in your office and you are kept as regular, you can inform me. I assure you that strict actions will be taken in this case by ICAI.

2. Non payment / irregular payment of stipend.

3. Exploitation, Harassment, etc. of any kind.

4. Force to work beyond normal working hours.

5. Illegal extension of articleship.

6. Sexual harassment ( I am shamful that I have to write this word here for the called professional CAs in my country)

7. Any other method which is directly/indirectly resulting in violation of CA Act and regulations made thereunder.


Regards.


Replies (48)

Moderators are requested not to delete this forum. It is sin to delete the truth.

heep it up my dear friend, 2 raise this pionts,

i think every one has suffer any one of the above point, but know one raise this points,

Good

Keep it UP

Now a days articles have to pay for articleship registration to CA...

& also CA is harassing in many ways...

Like not giving leave or so many matter as u write above..

We all are With u:)

Wake Up All CA Students..............

 

Well, I agree to all the points said above. But why are every CAs exploiting their article assistants and showing apathy to their woes?? Reason is that ICAI is governed by practising CAs..Is SEBI controlled by stock brokers, is IRDA controlled by Insurance Agents or is RBI controlled by bankers?? Definitely NO, if SEBI is controlled by stock brokers, they will mess things up and same with IRDA or RBI..so, in ICAI also the case is similar. Too much autonomy is given to practising members and they are controlling the affairs of ICAI..so, they frame rules and regulations as per their whims and fancies which suit their comfort. Its high time government control is brought in the functioning of ICAI or there is a chance of more chaos in ICAI's functioning.

Any one having grivance may make complaint to the Disciplinary Directorate of ICAI for necessary action.

we have to wake up and make complain to ICAI......

Dear Friend , don't blame the Qualified persons . If you don't like that just leave the course.

I have seen many frauds in Placement in Companies in India . The Exploitation is tremendous if you are a fresher . No one co-operates in this world . If fresher is employed , you are in stringent conditions lot of pressure and harassment and not completing targets which are overdriven leads to joblessness.

I am jobless for almost now 7 months after completing my MBA .Whom Should I complaint ? I was totally helpless . But God gave me a silver lining in a dark cloud . Hope it works , selected ICWA course this is last but not the least I pray to GOD. 

So never blame anyone dear ! If you fail it means it is not meant for you . I am damn serious . You may struggle for it , which is the last resort :/ No one can help on this. 

I also have hatred about ICAI highly experienced professionals , they think they are too great , Never Mind ,  I am damn serious  but I don't present it publicly. It implies you are frustrated .

Take care friend , change your line or try your level best . 

Wish you Good Luck in Career .:)

 

Originally posted by : Siddharth Surte

Dear Friend , don't blame the Qualified persons . If you don't like that just leave the course.

I have seen many frauds in Placement in Companies in India . The Exploitation is tremendous if you are a fresher . No one co-operates in this world . If fresher is employed , you are in stringent conditions lot of pressure and harassment and not completing targets which are overdriven leads to joblessness.

I am jobless for almost now 7 months after completing my MBA .Whom Should I complaint ? I was totally helpless . But God gave me a silver lining in a dark cloud . Hope it works , selected ICWA course this is last but not the least I pray to GOD. 

So never blame anyone dear ! If you fail it means it is not meant for you . I am damn serious . You may struggle for it , which is the last resort  No one can help on this. 

I also have hatred about ICAI highly experienced professionals , they think they are too great , Never Mind ,  I am damn serious  but I don't present it publicly. It implies you are frustrated .

Take care friend , change your line or try your level best . 

Wish you Good Luck in Career .

 

 

Yes, you are absolutely right. I am frustrated. I am frustrated because there are weak and stupid citizens like you in my country who do not dare to speak against injustice. People like you can just hide for the lifetime and keep saying that God is there and we should not think bad of others and such other worthless things. It is due to people like you that students are suffering today. Cowards cannot find a place for them on this earth, boy. You have to speak, otherwise the world will take you as dumb idiot.

I also know that you will not like to read the truth written by me in above lines, because you do not dare to speak in this kind of professional forums. Go and find any Girl-Boy joke forum for you.

Originally posted by : K15h0r K4thr4n1



Originally posted by : Siddharth Surte




Dear Friend , don't blame the Qualified persons . If you don't like that just leave the course.

I have seen many frauds in Placement in Companies in India . The Exploitation is tremendous if you are a fresher . No one co-operates in this world . If fresher is employed , you are in stringent conditions lot of pressure and harassment and not completing targets which are overdriven leads to joblessness.

I am jobless for almost now 7 months after completing my MBA .Whom Should I complaint ? I was totally helpless . But God gave me a silver lining in a dark cloud . Hope it works , selected ICWA course this is last but not the least I pray to GOD. 

So never blame anyone dear ! If you fail it means it is not meant for you . I am damn serious . You may struggle for it , which is the last resort  No one can help on this. 

I also have hatred about ICAI highly experienced professionals , they think they are too great , Never Mind ,  I am damn serious  but I don't present it publicly. It implies you are frustrated .

Take care friend , change your line or try your level best . 

Wish you Good Luck in Career .

 




 
Yes, you are absolutely right. I am frustrated. I am frustrated because there are weak and stupid citizens like you in my country who do not dare to speak against injustice. People like you can just hide for the lifetime and keep saying that God is there and we should not think bad of others and such other worthless things. It is due to people like you that students are suffering today. Cowards cannot find a place for them on this earth, boy. You have to speak, otherwise the world will take you as dumb idiot.


I also know that you will not like to read the truth written by me in above lines, because you do not dare to speak in this kind of professional forums. Go and find any Girl-Boy joke forum for you.

Sorry for interruption but mind that a professional should handle every case peacefully.  

Yes Yaar

But we have to change the rule and once this transferability is being removed, there will be a fair play and we can change the auditor when they are going beyond limits. I will prepair a Agenta which will include al developmental thoughts and send you all( It will be published in the CA CLUB and wil be givin in the Pres Conference.

BUT VIOLANCE IS NOT THE SOLUTION

i agree to siddharth surte

and dear kishore u can see the difference between you and siddhartha

he just wrote his view on it and u called him stupid and weak ....

i am here for last 3 years

and in practical life i have also seen a lot of students like you and siddhartha 

i can say one thing 

people like siddhartha succeed in the end.....

MODESTY IS THE BEST POLICY BUDDY 

i do not think that you are the only one in india who is suffering 

even i have suffered in this but this is called experiance

please generate some tolerance level within you otherwise it will surely give u pain in later ages

Good Luck

Greetings !!!

Really hats off to Kishor for bringing up a topic like this. :)

What he points out is THE true state of most Articled Assistants ;(.You are really Galliant to say it out loud and also aid for help to those affected.  Keep up the good work ! hope more people join up to revolt against the noble cause to bring up justice !

:)


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register