Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More



GST- Goods & Service Tax is one of the most crucial and major indirect tax reforms after independence to be implemented very soon (Probably from 01.04.2016). GST with its embedded element of simplicity in levy and collection of taxes as opposed to multiple / multi-point levy and collection of indirect tax, would remove the tax distortions besides reducing the cost of goods and services in the hands of the final consumer. With every individual, corporate, and professionals speaking about the positive impact on country’s growth, prosperity and GDP once the GST is implemented, let us understand what is GST, how it will work and how it will impact the Indian economy and how it will effect India globally.


GST is an indirect tax where consumption of goods and services are considered at the same level for the purpose of levy of tax. It is levied on manufacture, sale, import , consumption of goods and services. It will mostly substitute all indirect taxes collected on goods and services by the Central and State governments in India.


The framework for levy of indirect taxes under the Constitutional provisions in India vide Article 246, Seventh Schedule empowers both the Central Government and the State Governments to levy and collect applicable taxable-event based indirect taxes on transactions of goods and/or services. The taxable event varies from the point of manufacture or sale or provision of services or imports/exports. The existing indirect tax laws are origin-based tax, structured to levy and collect at the point of happening of the prescribed taxable event.

Diagrammatic representations of major components/constituents of Indirect Taxes are as follows:

The challenges embedded within the existing structure of Indirect Taxation in India leads to creation of obstacles and have an effect there under in the form of:

Challenges - nature

Leads to


• different tax rates on same product under existing VAT / Sales Tax under different States

Different prices due to different rates of tax levied and collected on the same commodity in the different states

no common economic market i.e. absence of integrated market

• not leveraging economies of scale

• Potential decrease in productivity and lower production

• Industries unable to gain the low-cost advantage

• Fixed overhead costs getting absorbed on lower scale of production

• Leverage for cost reduction through effective use of technology is not available to industries due to low economics of scale

• Higher cost of production for goods and services

• uncertainty in tax laws

• Constitutional pluralism

• Contradictory provisions

• Subordinate legislations

- Rules or Notifications or Circular in some cases tends to override the provisions of the mother Act

• multiplicity of taxes

• mystic aura of interpretation

• increase in litigation

• uncertainty for business / industries and Assesses under different tax laws

• multiplicity of compliance

• high compliance cost

• high litigation - arising out of issues majority relating to classification and valuation

• higher compliance cost

• anti-business tax environment

The present structure of taxation for goods and/or services in India:

• characterized as a cascading and distorted imposition of tax on production resulting in wrong allocation of resources and decreasing trend of productivity and declining the pace of economic growth.

• issues relating to double taxation - arising out of bifurcation of goods and services and differential treatment especially in the context of taxation of intangibles.

• inhibits voluntary compliance and leads to a narrow Tax/GDP ratio due to a narrow tax base.

How GST will work and how it will replace the present system:

GST is a value added tax, levied at each point in the supply chain with credit allowed for any tax paid on inputs acquired at each point for use in making the supply. It would apply to both goods and services in a comprehensive manner with exemptions restricted to a minimum.

India is opting for Concurrent Dual GST model. The need for a Dual-GST model is based on the following premise:

• At existing framework, both levels of Government i.e. Centre and State, as per Constitution holds concurrent powers to levy tax domestic goods and services;

• The proposed Concurrent Dual-GST model would be a dual levy imposed concurrently by the Centre and the States, but independently;

• Both the Centre and State will operate over a common base, i.e. the base for levy and imposition of duty/tax liability would be identical.

To understand the operating procedure of "Concurrent Dual GST Model"– we have to consider the tax/taxes which shall be levied as per place of supply of goods and services.

  1. CGST – Central Goods and Service Tax
  2. SGST – State Goods and Service Tax
  3. IGST – Integrated Goods and Service Tax

Additional Tax (up to 1%) to be levied in case of inter-state supply of goods, which is a non-vatable item. Hence, no input credit available on such

It is expected that the base and other essential design features would be common between CGST and SGST, across SGSTs for the individual States. Both CGST and SGST would be levied on the basis of the destination principle. Thus, exports would be zero-rated, and imports would attract the tax in the same manner as domestic goods and services. Inter-State supplies within India would attract an Integrated GST (aggregate of CGST and the SGST of the destination State).

In addition to the IGST, in respect of supply of goods, an additional tax of up to 1% has been proposed to be levied by the Centre. The revenue from this tax is to be assigned to the origin states. This tax is proposed to be levied for initial two years or such longer period as recommended by the GST Council.

Detailed discussion on "Models of GST" - CGST, SGST

A summary of levy and the imposing and collecting authority

Nature of Levy

To be levied by

To be paid to the

account of


Central Government on Intra-State Supply of Goods and/ or Services



State Government Intra State Supply of Goods and/ or Services



Central Government on Inter-State Supply of Goods and/ or Services


Additional Tax

Central Government on Inter-state supply of goods, but the net proceeds to be assigned to the States from where supply originates



Mr. A manufactures goods. He bought goods for Rs. 500000 and incurred expenses of Rs. 50,000. These manufactured goods were sold for Rs. 845.000. Say, CGST rate 10% & SGST rate 10%. Compute Sale Price.


Intra-state sale

Inter-state sale


Amount (Rs.)


Amount (Rs.)

Cost of Goods


Cost of Goods


Add: Expenses


Add: Expenses


Add: Profit ( = SP - TC)


Add: Profit ( = SP - TC)





SGST @ 10%


IGST @ 20%


CGST @ 10%


Additional Tax @ 1%


Sales Price


Sales Price


GST Coverage:

Coverage in general

The proposed GST in India would include All Goods & Services except:

i. Incentives to Industries which is to be converted into investment link cash subsidy

ii. Special Industrial Area Schemes which is to be also converted into investment based in the period they are valid

iii. Around 99 items presently exempted under VAT is proposed to continue in GST regime

iv. Common list of exemption for CGST & SGST

v. Transactions which are below threshold limits

It is also advised that there should not be exemption except in following cases:

i. All public services of Government (Central, State and Municipal / Panchayati Raj) including Civil Administration, Health Services & Formal Education Services provided by Government Schools & Colleges, Defence, Para-Military, Police, Intelligence & Government Departments.

ii. However, Public Services will not include Railways, Post & Telegraph, other Commercial Departments, Public Sector Enterprises, Banks & Insurance, and Health & Education Services.

iii. Any service transactions between an employer and employee either as a service provider, recipient or vice versa;

iv. Any unprocessed food article which is covered under the public distribution system should be exempt regardless of the outlet through which it is sold

v. Education services provided by an educational institution to its students, faculty and Staff --- Currently exempt under Mega Notification

vi. Health care services provided by a clinical establishment, authorised medical practitioner.

Taxes to be subsumed post-GST

This Bill specified that following Central indirect taxes and levies could be subsumed in GST:

1. Central Excise Duty,

2. Additional Excise Duties,

3. Excise Duty levied under the Medicinal and Toilet Preparations (Excise Duties) Act. 1955,

4. Service Tax,

5. Additional Customs Duty commonly known as Countervailing Duty (CVD),

6. Special Additional Duty of Customs (SAD),

7. Central Surcharges and Cesses excluding those applicable to income-tax, customs duties and to excise duties so far as they relate to goods outside the purview of the goods and services tax.

This Bill specified that following State indirect taxes and levies would be subsumed in GST:

1. State VAT/Sales Tax,
2. Entertainment tax (unless it is levied by the local bodies),
3. Luxury Tax,
4. Taxes on lottery,
5. Betting and gambling.
6. Tax on advertisements,
7. State Cesses and Surcharges insofar as they relate to supply of goods and services; and
8. Entry Tax, not levied by local bodies.

5.8.2: Other Indirect Taxes to continue post-GST

  1. Basic Custom Duty (Component of custom duty)
  2. Taxes on transactions in stock exchange (STT)
  3. Taxes on Lands & Building
  4. Taxes on mineral rights
  5. Duties of excise on alcoholic liquors, opium, Indian hemp, etc
  6. Stamp Duty (Clarification needed for different type of stamp duty)
  7. Taxes on professions, trades, employments
  8. Taxes on vehicles (subject to entry 35 of list III)
  9. Tolls
  10. Taxes on goods and passengers carried by road or on inland waterways

Tax Mechanism - Levy and Chargeability

The following are the proposals on GST mechanism.

Rate structure for Levy and Chargeability:

• Rates for CGST and SGST should be common across the states and shared between Central & State.

•There is no proper rate spelt till date; however, there are different rates suggested by different bodies.

• 4 rate structure for goods proposed:-

  1. Standard Rate
  2. Lower Rate – necessary items
  3. Special Rate – precious metals
  4. Exempted Items
  5. Exempted List to be finalized considering the goods and services of national importance and local importance.

Exports of Goods and Services to be Zero-rated.

Threshold Limit

Threshold limits (under indirect taxation) are synonymous to basic exemption limits or the maximum amount not chargeable to tax (under direct taxation). Under indirect taxation structure, threshold limits are the financial parameters of 'turnover' beyond which the 'tax payer' shall be liable for tax compliance.

The objectives behind threshold limit are:

(a) To reduce cost of administering of large number of tax payers;
(b) Relieve small tax payers from compliance cost and compliance administration;
(c) Give advantage to small tax payers over large enterprises on account of lower tax Incidence.

Threshold Limits under GST by Empowered Committee:

• Gross Annual turnover of Rs.10 lacs both for goods and services for all the States and Union Territories may be adopted with adequate compensation for the States (particularly states in North-Eastern Region and Special Category States)

• Threshold limits for CGST for goods Rs.1.5 crores and Rs.10 lacs for services are suggested

[However, Limit for CGST, SGST & IGST may remain same in the GST law]

Threshold Limits under GST by Task Force Report of Thirteenth Finance Commission:

• Uniform threshold limits for both CGST and SGST for all manufacturers, traders and service providers at Rs.10 lacs

• Existing exemption of Rs.150 lacs of turnover for small scale industries should not be continued under the GST framework.

Composition Scheme / Compounded Levy Scheme

Small dealers with annual aggregate turnover of goods and services between Rs.10 Lacs

— Rs. 40 Lacs may be allowed to opt for a compounded levy of 1%, each towards CGST and SGST, thereby 2% GST would be charged for compounded levy scheme.

Certain high value goods comprising of:

(a) Gold, silver and platinum ornaments;
(b) precious stones; and
(c) bullions

Are prone to smuggling due to high tax incidence. Therefore, it is recommended that dealers in such high value items may, without the ceiling of Rs. 40 Lacs, also be allowed to opt for the compounded levy of 1%, each towards CGST and SGST. No benefit of input credit would be extended to dealers opting for compounded levy scheme. Taxpayers opting for the compounded levy may be required to pay their taxes and file their returns on a quarterly basis. However, Empowered Committee of State finance ministers are of the view that 0.5% be the rate for compounding scheme of SGST and also the limit of compounded levy scheme be Rs.50 Lacs.

Note - The limit of Rs.40 Lacs is based on the consideration that dealers with turnover of Rs.40 Lacs or more are subject to tax audit under the Income Tax Act, 1961 and therefore they would suffer from many additional burden in terms of documentation under the GST.

We have extracted the below from speech of Finance Minister, Shri Pranab Mukherjee delivered at the meeting of the Empowered Committee of State Finance Ministers:

"The threshold for compounding for small dealers should also be uniform under CGST and SGST whether it is fixed at Rs. 50 lacs of turnover per annum or Rs.1 crore per annum. Of course, we must not lose sight of one of the critical deliverables of GST viz. that it should result in considerable simplification for small dealers so that compliance is easy and assured.

In short Finance Minister stated that threshold for compounding for small dealers should also be uniform under CGST and SGST whether it is fixed at Rs. 50 lacs of turnover per annum or Rs.1 crore per annum.

Comments of the Department of Revenue on the First Discussion Paper on GST Centre may also have a Composition Scheme up to gross turnover limit of Rs.50 lakh, if threshold for registration is kept as Rs. 10 lakh. The floor rate of 0.5% will be for SGST alone, in case Centre also brings a Composition Scheme for small assesses. The Centre may leave the administration of Compounding Scheme, both for CGST and SGST to the States. Bill was silent with respect to the compounded levy scheme.

EMAIL - jainedra1234@gmail.com/adishreebusinesssolutions@gmail.com

"Loved reading this piece by JAINENDRA JAIN?
Join CAclubindia's network for Daily Articles, News Updates, Forum Threads, Judgments, Courses for CA/CS/CMA, Professional Courses and MUCH MORE!"


Category Professional Resource, Other Articles by - JAINENDRA JAIN