LIVE GST Certification Course by CA Arun Chhajer begins 21st April. Register Now!!

Scrutiny assessment

Rani (None) (211 Points)

01 February 2013

Scrutiny assessment for individual tax payer for AY2009-10 was completed in Aug 2011. Order was received and addl tax paid. In Jan 2013, got a message from the CA to furnish some records for AY2009-10. What does it mean? No letter from ITO was received by the client. Is it part of the audit? I f so, is the client expected to get a notice from ITO? Can some one please enlighten?

Thanks,

Rani

Reply
Follow
Share

9 Replies

CA MAYANK WADHERA (CA CS CMA(I)) (789 Points)
Replied 01 February 2013

Please contact your CA he will clarify about this.

1 Like

Nikhil Kaushik (Fellow CA) (84841 Points)
Replied 02 February 2013

pleas check with ur CA. in general it is possible that income tax authorities may have asked for certain information under section 133, 148 or 154. but in any case, don't provide any information unless u have the copy of the notice made available to u by ur CA.

1 Like

Rani (None) (211 Points)
Replied 02 February 2013

I checked with the CA. I was told that it was just a phone call from ITO. Since I used the services of CA only for scrutiny assessment, I was asked to contact the ITO directly. I have not received any notice from ITO. I am not sure what I am supposed to go and tell the ITO.

Thanks,

Rani

Nikhil Kaushik (Fellow CA) (84841 Points)
Replied 02 February 2013

Hi Rani,

You have two options.

1. go to the assessing officer directly. Carry the assessment order for the relevant assessment year with you. Try and understand what he/ she is asking for. If there are any specific questions asked, you may ask for adequate time to file replies (provided the assessing officer is within his/ her jurisdiction to ask you those questions)

2. Engage your earlier CA or any new CA to do the above on your behalf.

I don't know where you reside, but I shall glad to help you professionally in this matter.

Rani (None) (211 Points)
Replied 22 February 2013

I met with the IT officer. This was regarding an audit query. I have submitted the relevant documents. To all experts in the forum : how does an audit query get closed? Is there a time limit for closing an audit query? Who is authorized to close the query - IT officer or audit team?

Thanks in advance.

Rani (None) (211 Points)
Replied 22 February 2013

Just wanted to add that the notice received was u/s 154/155.

Nikhil Kaushik (Fellow CA) (84841 Points)
Replied 23 February 2013

under which sub-section of 155?

with regards to power to close audit queries - I dont have much idea - but you refer to https://nadt.gov.in/%28S%28iynvx145fv4d5zayuekzt2ra%29%29/writereaddata/MenuContentImages/A%20Hand%20Book%20on%20Audit634729512737059215.pdf

1 Like

Rani (None) (211 Points)
Replied 23 February 2013

Thanks Nikhil. It just says " there is an apparent mistake from the record within the meaning of section 154/155". This is regarding LTCG of mutual funds. I have bought debt mutual fund units (NAV Rs.10/-) and sold them after an year for about 10% gain (NAV 11.xx) and availed indexation benefits. The audit team has taken the purchase price as 10% of the original cost (why and how , I don't know) which had given me a 1000% appreciation in a span of slightly more than an year and demands tax on the capital gain! such an appreciation is not possible in any type of asset class.

I have submitted the purchase documents and hope they would close it.