Out of syllabus question In May 11 Ca Final ?

Final 1330 views 8 replies

Nikhil

140 Points Joined January 2008

Two questions were asked from winding up chapter carrying 8 marks each from other than paragraph 9.4 of chapter 9 of corporate and allied laws. Following was the printed part of notification in RTP May 2011 as well as student newsletter :

Applicability of relevant Amendments/Circulars/Notifications/Regulations etc. relating to Corporate and Allied Laws for May 2011, Examination: Subject Matter	CA Final – Corporate and Allied Laws
Companies Bill, 2009	Not applicable
Easy Exit Scheme, 2011	Not Applicable
Provisions relating to Revival and Rehabilitation of Sick-Industrial Companies	Not applicable
Companies (Second Amendment) Act, 2002 [relating to Winding Up]	Not applicable [Students have been advised to studyonly the general provisions of winding up as covered under Paragraph 9.4 of chapter 9 of the study material]
SEBI (Issue of Capital and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2009	Applicable (Amendments upto April 2010

I urge all of the students community to urge to Board of studies to give us compensation against these questions.This mistake is being done from May,2010. Please help.....

Replies (8)

Vijay

Adamo Studio

2112 Points Joined March 2011

ICAI he chalta rehta hai

rahul

Chartered Accountant

5572 Points Joined June 2010

always happen in CA final.

CA ADITYA SHARMA

CA IN PRACTICE

16719 Points Joined May 2011

ALWAYS HAPPENS

Mohit Kansal

92 Points Joined April 2009

CA me sub chalta hai Nikhil

CA Mohit Saxena

FINANCE MANAGER

343 Points Joined June 2008

icai d killing machine bt remember one thing friends,

"paas hone ki tamannna ab hamare dil me hai, dekhna hai jor kitna bajue QATIL (ICAI) me hai.

Saurabh Mittal

CA Final Ambala Cantt

39 Points Joined October 2010

i already mailed to ICAI Team members and they acknowledge me with credit of this point.

Avanish Soni

47 Points Joined April 2009

Man , you're doing chartered accountant course , try to read the notification full and understand. There was nothing out of course in Law paper.

In Notification it's given Compaines second amendment act prov. relating to Winding up is Not applicable excpet Genreal Prov. , there is no where written that Comapnies act, 1956 prov. are N.A . Only given that second amendmend act Prov relating to Winding up NA excpet General Prov carried out Second amendment act.

That means Co. act 1956 prov and Genreal prov. carried out by second amed. act 2002 are applicable. Every question was from course, noting was out of course.