How to find a good CA

It may sound like an easy thing to do. But I have tried everything including working with dozen of CA firms.

I feel the quality is always missing. Everyone is trying to do mediocre job and mark it as done even if I pay them hourly rates. Some firms just delegate to junior accountants who did sh*tty job again.

Any recommendation on finding top CA firms in India with highest quality of work and professionalism? I am happy to pay higher rates

Replies (9)
Quick Summary
Finding a high-quality Chartered Accountant (CA) firm in India can be challenging, with many businesses experiencing a lack of attention to detail and professionalism. To find a good firm, consider engaging them on a specific project first to evaluate their work quality, turnaround time, and communication. For complex needs, large firms like Deloitte or EY are options, but always clarify who will handle your work and their review process. For SMEs, a mid-sized firm with partner involvement might be more suitable. Focus on relevant experience and review processes over just reputation or fees.

Engage the firm or consultant on a single, well-defined project (e.g., a comprehensive tax health check, standard operating procedure overhaul, or book finalization review).

Evaluate their output based on attention to detail, proactive identification of tax risks/savings, turnaround speed, and communication quality.

For complex corporate taxation, statutory audits, and financial reporting, firms such as Deloitte, EY, PwC, KPMG, Grant Thornton Bharat, and BDO India are worth considering. However, the right choice depends on your business needs and the expertise of the team handling your work.

Before finalising a firm, ask who will actually handle the assignment, how closely a senior professional will review it, and who will be accountable for the final deliverables. You can also request a sample report with confidential details removed to assess the quality of their work.

For SMEs, a specialised mid-sized CA firm with active partner involvement may be a better fit if you want more direct attention. Compare firms based on relevant experience, review processes, and track record rather than reputation or fees alone. Agreeing on the scope, timelines, and communication process upfront can also help avoid misunderstandings.

@ Aashok

I have tried several 1-50 people firms in the past.

During the inital meeting, senior CA discuss the project. Once hired, they delegate work to junior accountants who always do a sh*tty job.

@ Thinking Bridge

I don't think I am big enough for these big firms (around 50L net profit per year)

I have worked with mid-sized firms. They had good google reviews. They confirmed 4 senior CA review every single piece of work.

But it was all lie. For example, the tax litigation work done by the junior accountant was full of grammar mistakes, completely unreadable and wrote paypal as the client I work for instead of writing actual client name and treating paypal as payment processor.

Nobody has any ethics or shame.

Check the defined Scope of Work, deliverables, turnaround time (TAT), and review/quality assurance clauses. Identify specific SLAs or SOP conditions that were breached (e.g., unauthorized delegation to junior staff without review, missed statutory deadlines, incorrect filing). Send an official written communication detailing the specific SOP deviations, quality deficiencies, or errors. Provide a specified timeline (e.g., 7 to 14 days) to rectify the work without additional fees, or request a refund/adjustment of professional fees for unperformed or poorly executed services. Terminate the engagement per the contract’s termination clause. Under ICAI Code of Ethics, if you appoint a new CA, the new CA must issue a No Objection Certificate (NOC) or communication to the previous CA before accepting the assignment.

If the CA’s performance involves gross negligence, misrepresentation, or failure to exercise due care, you can file a complaint with the Disciplinary Directorate of ICAI under the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949.
Applicable Violations Under ICAI Schedules:

  • Gross Negligence: Failing to exercise due diligence or being grossly negligent in performing professional duties (Clause 7, Part I, Second Schedule).
  • Failure to Disclose Material Facts: Expressing opinions or certifying reports without verifying underlying records or concealing material facts (Clause 5 & 6, Part I, Second Schedule).
  • Delegation without Oversight: Engaging unauthorized non-employees/unqualified personnel without taking professional responsibility.

Summary - If a CA delivers poor quality work or breaches contract SOPs, you can issue a formal breach notice to rectify or refund fees, terminate the contract, and transition to a new CA following ICAI NOC guidelines. For gross negligence or misconduct, you can file a complaint with the ICAI Disciplinary Directorate (which can levy fines or suspend practice), and initiate Civil or Consumer Court proceedings for recovery of financial losses due to breach of contract or deficiency of service.

I hope you understand I have more important things to do in life than complaining about different CA's to ICAI.

Your experience is common, and the fix is mostly in how you set up the engagement, not in finding a perfect firm.

Before you sign anything, ask for these:
1. The name of the person who will actually prepare your work, and the name of the person who will review it. Ask for the reviewer's sign-off in writing on each deliverable (reply, return, computation).
2. A sample of a past notice reply or appeal with client details removed. Grammar and structure in the sample tell you more than Google reviews.
3. A fixed scope and timeline per matter, with one person you can call directly.
4. For tax litigation, ask who drafts the submission and who appears before the officer or CIT(A). Those are often different people.

Two practical habits on your side:
- Read every draft before it goes out. Wrong client name or wrong assessment year are caught in two minutes by the owner.
- Start with one matter, like Aashok Kumar Sharma suggested, and judge on accuracy and turnaround before moving the rest of the work.

At your size, a smaller practice where a partner is hands-on will usually give better review than a large firm that treats Rs 50 lakh profit as a small client. Happy to talk through what a good scope looks like if you want, but the checklist above works with any firm.

Your experience is common, and the fix is mostly in how you set up the engagement, not in finding a perfect firm.

Before you sign anything, ask for these:
1. The name of the person who will actually prepare your work, and the name of the person who will review it. Ask for the reviewer's sign-off in writing on each deliverable (reply, return, computation).
2. A sample of a past notice reply or appeal with client details removed. Grammar and structure in the sample tell you more than Google reviews.
3. A fixed scope and timeline per matter, with one person you can call directly.
4. For tax litigation, ask who drafts the submission and who appears before the officer or CIT(A). Those are often different people.

Two practical habits on your side:
- Read every draft before it goes out. Wrong client name or wrong assessment year are caught in two minutes by the owner.
- Start with one matter, like Aashok Kumar Sharma suggested, and judge on accuracy and turnaround before moving the rest of the work.

At your size, a smaller practice where a partner is hands-on will usually give better review than a large firm that treats Rs 50 lakh profit as a small client. Happy to talk through what a good scope looks like if you want, but the checklist above works with any firm.

The issue may be less about finding the highest-priced firm and more about defining quality and accountability upfront. Shortlist firms with relevant experience in your specific requirement, ask who will do and review the work, and request a paid pilot with agreed deliverables, review stages, timelines and escalation points. Check references for similar assignments and assess the actual reviewer—not just the partner pitching the engagement.

For recurring accounting, compliance or audit-support work, map the workflow and quality checks before assigning it to a firm. Manual practice work is difficult to manage consistently, and automation can reduce repetitive effort while leaving professional judgment and final review in control. Our platform offers 2,000+ AI agents and 650+ integrations covering only relevant workflows. If you’d like to discuss a workflow fit, you’re welcome to WhatsApp https://wa.me/message/3HVOZ7HIY4ESC1.

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Company
10 November 2026
FP&A Executive

Gujarat Guardian

Ankleshwar

CA Final

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 14 November 2026
Article Assistant

Jitendra Agarwal & Associates

Bengaluru

CA Inter

View Details
Company
20 November 2026
Article

S & N CO

Mumbai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
20 November 2026
Senior Accountant

Compass Tex India Pvt Ltd

Coimbatore

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 07 November 2026
Article Assisstant

DPV & Associates

Chennai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
19 November 2026
Accounts & Taxation Executive

MCSR and Associates LLP

Hyderabad

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured ARTICLESHIP 31 October 2026
CA Articleship

apricus india

Navi Mumbai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured 07 November 2026
Chartered Accountant

DPV & Associates

Chennai

CA

View Details