Finance/Compliance Consultant
78104 Points
Posted on 06 November 2026
Key defences for a Sec 74 SCN on "double e-way bills" for FY 2018-19:
• Limitation: Sec 74(10) allows an order within 5 years of the due date of the annual return for that year. For FY 2018-19 the GSTR-9 due date (extended) was 31 December 2020, so the order limit is 31 December 2025. The SCN must be issued at least 6 months before (Sec 74(2)). Check the SCN date; it may be time-barred.
• Sec 74 needs fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression. Duplicate e-way bills generated by error (with no corresponding supply, no second invoice in GSTR-1, no payment, no movement) show no suppression. Also, an audit (Sec 65) for the same period was completed without this observation. Argue that invoking the extended period is unjustified.
• Merits: an e-way bill alone is not evidence of supply. Produce:
– invoice-wise mapping of both EWBs to the single invoice
– vehicle/RFID data showing one movement
– the buyer's confirmation
– stock and ledger records.
• Request cross-verification, and a personal hearing (Sec 75(4)).
• If it ends in a Sec 73 order instead, the Sec 128A waiver may apply for FY 2018-19 (interest and penalty waived if tax was paid by the notified date). Check eligibility.