I feel the results are manupulated.

Even i lost my 2nd group in june attempt with 6 marks in aggregate,,,,, There is surely some manipulation going on.... which is not good for deserving candidates.......

i totally agree with you all....i also lost my second group in last exam only by 5 marks in total

you all should not question the reputation of our institute by one such instance which may be true in that individual student case donot generalise and come to conclusions

I Too....,,,,,,,,, feel the same that there had been some manipulation been done

manupulations r going on guys... u can conclude d manupulations in 2nd group from d fact dat they r claiming increase in passing percentage of both grps n 1st grp....but they did not reveal d passing percentage of 2nd grp...in passing percentage of both grps they hv included those students also who failed in 2nd grp but managed to clear both grps on d basis of aggregate of both grps or managed to clear both grps on the basis of 1st grp... among my frnds only 3 guys cleared pcc n dat too on d basis of their 1st grp result none of dem passed 2nd grp on agrregate...if institute thinks dat students r not doing well in 2nd grp or they r not writting their papers well enough 2 clear n why dont dey show us our valuated marksheet n tell us our mistakes...a student works equally hard 4 both grps den why is it dat they dnt get equally gud marks in 2nd grp... further i read in one of d analysis of icai's result analysis that 2nd grp students r non serious...they fail 2 get basic 40 marks in each subject... but they were not able 2 think that why students fail 2 get basic 40 marks in 2nd grp ony.....

rght guys....

i thnk institue is doin manipulation

hey any one knows wat is the administrative structure of ICAI-- they have all members who are CA or others also like members frm finance ministry or other govt departments

I got 7 marks increase in nov 2008 exams

Originally posted by : D н ! я σ √
	I've been in this syllabus since 3 years and heard so many people getting retotalling (revaluation) of their results... But none, NO ONE of them ever said that their results were changed......... I mean, i heard this first time that anyone got POSITIVE response from ICAI....

With all due respect to the guys claiming an increase in the marks it would be nice if they show some proff for the same like photo copy of the two mark sheets or something like that.. Its not that we don believe u but its better to be talking with some evidence..

It would certainly add more credence to your statement..

Its hard to belive that ppl get 20 marks more in retotalling, last time i cudn clear group 1 (short by 6 Marks),gave ppl for retotallin and den to no change , n agreed with institute manipulatin the results

Its the 1st time , i guess when nov attemp results declared in feb : (

i totally agree with all you guys i.e. there is some manipulation goin on ......... if not than why is the result late &  always postponed !!!

Originally posted by : HARPREET SINGH
	ICAI  IS  LOSING ITS REPUTATION ITSELF BY GIVING  SUCH RUBBISH ANNOUNCEMENTS..............

extremel right... this is the 2nd time they are doing like so... people's will loose faith on institute...

i too surely believe that results are being manipulated.ICAI should announce about the problem it is facing only for pcc/pe-2 but not for the others.

I FEEL THE SAME WAY THAT THERE IS SOMETHING MANIPULATION IS GOING ON EVEN I LOST MY SECOND GROUP IN JUNE ATTEMPT BY JUST 6 MARKS IN AGGREGATE

U r 101% right