How was Law Paper (CA Final) ?????

you all are FCA

Future Chartered Accountants

ya its true that 16 marks question is out of course.in RTP as well mentioned that Winding Ups Basic questions only asked....and ans of FEMA  question- mr bhattacharya is PROI.

Yes, winding up was out of syllabus. We should get together and write to ICAI about this.  Something must be done. Can't assume that ICAI would voluntarily do justice. Also, we should not let this pass without protest. 

Ya every 1 must go & write to president for asking question on Winding up out of course

Guys I Think Everyone should Send Mail Reporting On Dat Winding Up Part.... So That Atleast We can Have Chances to Pass.... 

WINDING UP was Hot topic in OLD Syllabus, To give some reward to OLDIES such questions were asked. Now OLD or NEW everyone is a CA student. Accept the Paper AS IT IS. 

CA is a Profession where you u shud not select material for preparation.

THOSE WHO ARE AGAINST WINDING UP QUESTION WILL SURELY FAIL. TAKE MY WORDS GRANTED. THE FRUSTRATION IS COMIN OUT OF U !!

Coming back to Bhattacharya story, HE IS A PROI.....BECAUSE SECOND PART OF DEFINITION READS AS "  IN  EITHER CASE OTHERWISE THAN TAKING UP EMPLOYMENT IN INDIA......................."

@  aravind - bhatachharyya is PROI - because the stay is less than 182 days. when the period of stay is less than 182 days - the purpose for which he returned back is irrelevant and immaterial....

friends i dont think icai will do justice because winding up is such an important topic. and the question was also not so tough to that part... the question paper was overall an easy one.

@ anirudh - mr a can inspect the books irrespective of the shareholding only if authorized to do so by AoA

I AM 500% SURE Mr. BHATTACHARYYA WAS PRI.

if you are not agree, then i will tell you after exam

BEST OF LUCK OF 2nd Group

@ Anirudh...

Mr. A Cannot inspect .. it was a question on section 209...

He is a member and so he cant inspect...

One option was that he can get himself nominated as a director and then he is eligible to inspect the books of accounts..

It is a question from May 2010 paper...

Originally posted by : abhishek agarwal
	@ arvind  mr bhattcharya wud be PRI....

 no he will be proi coz he resides in india for less then 183 days in preceding fy

Originally posted by : Harshit Talati
	@ Anirudh... Mr. A Cannot inspect .. it was a question on section 209... He is a member and so he cant inspect... One option was that he can get himself nominated as a director and then he is eligible to inspect the books of accounts.. It is a question from May 2010 paper...

 i think the question is related to section 235(2)

from last attempt it was top...