Discuss and Download CA Final Exam question paper Nov 2013

ok , hope for the best and look forward for next 3 paper

thanks a lot for your insight frnz ...it'd be really useful for many people like me  who are preparing for may attempt 

very very lengthy and tough both kya kare

1) Amalgamation Question

Note: 100 shareholders of Sunny Ltd. did not consent to the amalgamation. 

Actually this question was with missing details. It was not given that 100 share holders were holding how many shares ?

2) Brand Valuation

I personally thought the answer should be ZERO. because no branded company will menufacture unbranded goods and moreover will outsource BRANDED GOODS.

Then there is no value of its brand..!!!

Its like what is the value of CA Course if ICAI outsource CA Course/ICAI to Universities and starts running B.Com. Course.?

Best of Luck to all of you people for your SFM Paper.

Its now time for ICAI to change the format of CA course from very base. Its like craming through sterio type classes material and pass out exams. No quality of Qualified CA.

There is no practicality in questions asked. Its worthless to assess a student by giving 180 minutes to prove himself by answering impractical questions. This FR paper will not be solved by at least 90% of Qualified Chartered Accountants in total History of CA course even though they are given 60 minutes extra to READ 16 PAGES PAPER.

Value of CA is reducing because of this only. I have written an e-mail to Board of Studies, ICAI also about this issue even before exams but as usual NO REPLY.!!

Definitely a very lenghty paper running into 15 pages. I hope ICAI president looks into this and make the corrections easier.

Very Lengthy paper.ICAI has to take step to give questions which can be answered in 180 minutes

friends,

upload sfm papers

Why is today nobody discussing about CA FInal SFM paper..??
And please somebody upload the paper please..??

everybody discussing there paper on fb 

Not difficuilt.. manageable

 can someone confirm if there is a mistake in Q 6(a) part as it should have growth instead of rate of return.

Originally posted by : Abhinav
	can someone confirm if there is a mistake in Q 6(a) part as it should have growth instead of rate of return.

YES IT WAS A MISTAKE.BUT WE CAN WRITE SUCH MISTAKE AS AN ASSUMPTION.BOTH FR AND SFM WAS VERY TOUGH