Auditors' reaction on Satyam saga

Secondary Mkt 1348 views 6 replies

 Auditors' reaction on Satyam saga

7 Jan 2009, 1520 hrs IST, ET Bureau

 News of cooked up numbers in the Satyam Computers balance sheet has rattled the accounting profession. Here are a few

 

reactions.

 

Richard Rekhy, COO, KPMG in India

 

The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India will do an investigation of its own to check whether there was an audit failure. The council has its own disciplinary committee that will see whether adequate due diligence was ensured by the auditor.

 

An independent investigating agency can probe the role of the senior management, the banks, other directors, because the amount involved is also too huge.

 

Since it is an SEC-registered company, there will be an independent investigation from the US also. Overall, I think it is a loss of reputation for the accounting profession and will also throw up the role of independent directors in the whole matter.

 

Suresh Surana, chairman, RSM India

 

It needs to be ascertained whether any documentary evidence was presented to the auditors, on whether that was forged. Also since it is regarding large sums of money, what was the role of the banks?

 

This would now show that there is too much focus on the short-term performance of a company, on quarterly performance. This is sometimes at the expense of the long term status of the company.

Replies (6)

It is the greed of the investors expecting high returns, greed of the management expecting top position, greed of the stakeholders expecting huge rewards, greed of the auditors expecting more fees, greed of the competitors expecting fall of rival, greed of the media for breaking news, greed of us expecting better governance system. It is only GREED!!!!!!!

 but there is no as ---on greed---ha ha

Satyam in sanskit means "truth". ................also satyam when written in reverse order results in "Maytas" .......which obviously is opposite of truth........thus when fraud was discovered truth prevailed over false................

Entire Indian audit techniques were outdated like the weapons Indian Police men did possess.

 this is frustrating.  All the large audit firms were very proud of their ethics committees, their governance policy, their vision, their working papers, what happened to everything in the case of Satyam.  Was it in the closet, or buried in the ground.

There is no sense of any audit practice, the brand of the entire profession is tarnished.  

Originally posted by :Prakash Popat
" Entire Indian audit techniques were outdated like the weapons Indian Police men did possess. "

I think real culprit is not Satyam, it is PWC. People do not trust the accounts of any company, they trust the accounts if it is certified by CA. If investors are looted, so book the PWC under IPC and immediately put them behind the bars there partners who are incharge of the audit of satyam


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register