Why?? can anyone dare to answer....?

others 2696 views 95 replies

Why CA doing students are not that good in communication and presentation when compared to MBA doing students??

 

 

Why most of the CA doing students particularly girls look very average compared to MBA doing Students??

 

 

Why CA students fumble while arguing with MBA qualified students.??

 

 

Why CA students work like a clerk even after qualifying the final level??

 

Why most of the CA's could not take business decisions unlike MBA's??

 

 

 

Replies (95)

Why did u post all these Questions??

Originally posted by : rohit

Why did u post all these Questions??

I didnot get ur answer properly.....

What exactly you mean to say???

Why you have such Misunderstanding....
In ICAI conference you can find out what presentation
skill our CA's have.....
Its about the mentality and own career decision of doing
CA, not about girl and boy....
Profession demands humbleness, never fumble..
And yeah... CAs are boss of clerks...

Much more to say...

ICAI is creating world-class CA which are in competition
and even much better than MBAs...
devil

Place ur profession above all.... u will start finding differences... its all ur misconceptions....

develop the skills u lak in... CAs are and will always be above all....

best wishes..... yes

Originally posted by : Urvashi

Why you have such Misunderstanding....
In ICAI conference you can find out what presentation
skill our CA's have.....
Its about the mentality and own career decision of doing
CA, not about girl and boy....
Profession demands humbleness, never fumble..
And yeah... CAs are boss of clerks...

Much more to say...

ICAI is creating world-class CA which are in competition
and even much better than MBAs...
 
VERY WELL SAID 

 

There is nothing which require a daring to say about a CA or CA student.  

.

Every one has his own story, here. The story of PREMA JAYKUMAR - The First Rank Holder in CA Final Exam has recently been published. Nothing new or abnormal has been felt because.... here...every one has got his own set of problems.  Had PREMA dreamt a career in MBA !!!! Could she not do that ?. We have got a number of such stories. 

.

The day will be great in the Indian History, when MBA institutes will start to carve the careers of  Millions of such talanted students who can not afford the higher costs of studies.  Till now- if you have heard about any of such student ....who ever had topped the MBA course in the similar challanging conditions- let us know.

.

The dedication, sacrifice, adjustment in the personal and social life, hard working nature, 

problem solving capacity,  updation and acquaintance with the rapid changes under

various national and international laws,  and so many other qualities  may also be   

suitably considered as criteria in the comparative analysis for a TRUE & FAIR  view.

.

 

Why CA doing students are not that good in communication and presentation when compared to MBA doing students??

not good in communication & presentation ?? seriously ??? 

have you ever been to any national convention programs organized by institute every year ??? if not , attend it . you ll get to know that no one ll ever do such a marvellous presentation than a CA student .

Why most of the CA doing students particularly girls look very average compared to MBA doing Students??    

you are attending classes to read something or to just see how the girls look ? appearence is something which a girl should be worried for . girls arent for marketting job that they hav to look more pretty to attract clients for their companies .

Why CA students fumble while arguing with MBA qualified students.??  

i can understand you are a die hard fan of MBA . but that does not mean CA is less . even i can say that the nature of MBA is nothing but arguing for everything .

Why CA students work like a clerk even after qualifying the final level?? 

simple !!! the student does not remain as a student after being qualified . he just works hard to make his own identity in the society .

Why most of the CA's could not take business decisions unlike MBA's??   there are many chartered accountants who are successful enterpreneus . they dint need any MBA degree to make their business successful . talent is what matters . a mere qualification is of no use . there are many CA's who are expert in other than financial fields . 

 

I dint mean to hurt any MBA out here .. But at the same time , your post is something which would instigate any CA proffessionals or students for that matter ... there are many times at which a student would think to quit the course .. even am not an exception in this . but CA is something more than just a proffesion . it meants a life to many .. a dream come true ... dont make it a cheap by saying "girls look average and students look like clerks " .. apearence is something the way we look and is completely the choice of an individual . you have no say in it ..

CA Deepak Parekh Chairman of HDFC CA K.M.Birla Chairman of Birla Groups. MBA Toppers dream of working in these companies.
Originally posted by : Komal shuklaa

FIRST U MEET ARE I AM THE CORRECT PERSON FOR UR QUESTION AND IAM SAYING,

I WILL DEFINETLY KILL UR IGO

 

MY gmail id santoo.1538 @ gmail.com
 

 

 

 

PLEASE FIND A LINK HERE TO GO TO MBA SITE,

https://WWW.MBACLUBINDIA.COM

CA IS THE NUMBER ONE IN ALL OVER INDIA......MAY BE MBA FROM TOP BUSINES SCHOOLS CAN COMES CLOSE TO CA.

 

the simple way to get answers for your questions.

"Register for CA course immediately"

at that moment you find  what is CA ? 

Respected Komal,

 

Just tell me few things

 

Why everyone ask a candiate ki From Where have you done MBA and not from CA?

Why a CA who has scored 50% i.e he is pass gets a job quickly and MBA with same percentage does not?

Why can not a MBA sign a balance sheet?
 

Why the biggest superstar of our Country say Amitabh Bachhan, run after CA for his autographer, and not a MBA

Why in any job reqiuremnet of Finance it is mentioned that the Candidate should be CA / MBA from a recognised university with first class percentage.

Please respect your profession, only then it will respect you and please stop comparing with anyone

Originally posted by : Urvashi

Why you have such Misunderstanding....
In ICAI conference you can find out what presentation
skill our CA's have.....
Its about the mentality and own career decision of doing
CA, not about girl and boy....
Profession demands humbleness, never fumble..
And yeah... CAs are boss of clerks...

Much more to say...

ICAI is creating world-class CA which are in competition
and even much better than MBAs...
 

your answer is looking like a rhyming poetry....but you didnot answer direct to my question.

I agree very few CA studens may have excelled in ICAI conference. but what about the majority of the students?? 

I agree humbleness required but my question is why they fumble while arguing???

@ CA Paras Bafna sir.....

Thanks for the reply........but you also did not reply to my questionwise..

I heard about the topper....

These kind of students are also one the reason why CA's dont excel in communication and presentation...

Since these kind of students did their schooling from thier vernacular medium......

 


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply