Whether Indexed Capital Loss Can Be Claimed Under the Optional 20% Tax Regime for Immovable Property

Dear Experts,

I have come across an interesting issue regarding the taxation of long-term capital gains on the transfer of land under the amended provisions applicable to immovable property.

Facts of the case:

  • Sale Consideration: ₹35,00,000
  • Actual Cost of Acquisition: ₹18,44,590
  • Indexed Cost of Acquisition: ₹46,86,256

Accordingly:

  • Without indexation:
    • LTCG = ₹16,55,410
    • Tax @ 12.5% = ₹2,06,927 (approx.)
  • With indexation:
    • Long-term Capital Loss = ₹11,86,256

While preparing the return, the ITR utility initially computes tax at 12.5% on the unindexed capital gain and thereafter grants relief by comparing it with the tax under the indexed method, effectively resulting in Nil tax. However, it does not recognize the indexed capital loss for the purpose of set-off or carry forward.

My query is:

The amended provisions give the assessee an option to pay tax either:

  1. @ 12.5% without indexation, or
  2. @ 20% after considering indexation (where applicable).

If the indexed computation results in a capital loss instead of a capital gain, why should such loss not be eligible for set-off or carry forward under sections governing capital losses?

I have not been able to locate any express statutory prohibition, CBDT Circular, or judicial precedent directly dealing with this issue.

I would appreciate the views of the learned members, along with any statutory references, CBDT clarifications, or judicial decisions that may throw light on this issue.

Thank you.

Replies (4)
Quick Summary
This discussion explores whether an indexed capital loss can be claimed and carried forward when opting for the 20% tax regime on immovable property sales. While the tax utility may not initially recognise such a loss, it is argued that an indexed capital loss arising from the 20% with indexation option is indeed allowable. This loss can be set off against other long-term capital gains in the same year and carried forward for up to eight years.

The current tax utility and legal framework do not recognize the negative result of an "indexed calculation" as a legitimate capital loss. The relief provided by the Finance Act (No. 2) 2024 is strictly limited to restricting the tax liability to the old regime's levels; it explicitly does not permit the carry forward of any loss arising from the indexation benefit.

Yes, an indexed capital loss CAN arise under the 20% with indexation option, and it is an allowable loss. Here is how it works: For property sold between April 1, 2024 and July 22, 2024 (Period 1): - Default rate was 20% with indexation. - If the indexed cost of acquisition exceeds the sale consideration, you have an LTCL (Long-Term Capital Loss). - This LTCL is allowable and can be set off against other long-term capital gains in the same year. Balance can be carried forward for 8 years and set off against future LTCG. For property sold on or after July 23, 2024 (Period 2): - Default is 12.5% without indexation. - For individual or HUF sellers who acquired the property before July 23, 2024: the proviso under Section 112 allows an optional election for 20% with indexation. - If you elect 20% with indexation and the indexed cost exceeds sale price: same treatment applies, it is a valid LTCL. Key point: The option to elect 20% with indexation is available at the time of filing your ITR. The ITR-2 computation utility will compute both options. You choose the one that is more beneficial, which in a loss scenario IS the 20% indexation route (it gives you a recognized loss to carry forward). Note: The ITR-2 AY 2026-27 has a known validation issue in Schedule CG. Before finalizing, ensure the period-wise split (before/after July 23) is correctly entered or the validation will fail. This [capital gains tax guide for property sellers](https://taxgarden.in/blog/tax-on-sale-of-property-india-capital-gains-seller-guide-ay-2026-27) has the full period-wise computation framework for AY 2026-27.

Does it permit set off of ltcg capital loss with ltcg capital gain both with indexation for 2 properties sold in 2025 ? 

On the stated figures, the comparison appears to determine the tax on a positive LTCG—not create an indexed capital loss for set-off or carry-forward. The statutory computation of income and the tax-rate comparison are separate questions.

  • For transfers on or after 23 July 2024, section 112(1)(a) provides the 12.5% rate without indexation. The proviso to section 112(1) gives a specified resident individual/HUF a comparison-based safeguard for qualifying land or building acquired before that date: tax on the transfer is limited to the lower of tax computed under the amended provision and tax computed under the pre-amendment provision.
  • On your figures, the indexed computation produces a loss of ₹11,86,256, not a positive capital-gain tax liability. That comparison may reduce the tax on the unindexed gain to nil; it does not, by itself, turn the alternative indexed computation into a loss under the head “Capital gains.”
  • Set-off and carry-forward under sections 70, 71 and 74 apply to a loss computed under the Act under the relevant head. The comparison proviso does not expressly provide for recognising or carrying forward a loss arising only in the alternative tax computation. The utility’s treatment is consistent with that distinction, though it is not itself statutory authority.
  • Accordingly, on the facts given, I would not claim the ₹11,86,256 as a set-off/carry-forward loss solely on the basis of the rate-comparison proviso. Check the exact transfer date, residential status, asset qualification and applicable assessment year; those determine whether the proviso applies. I am not aware of a directly applicable CBDT clarification or reported decision on this specific loss question.

This issue sits at the intersection of capital-gain computation, rate comparison and return reporting. Manual work across alternative computations can be difficult; automation reduces repetitive checks while keeping professional judgment in control. Our platform offers 2,000+ AI agents and 650+ integrations covering relevant tax, accounting and compliance workflows. For a workflow discussion, message us on WhatsApp at https://wa.me/message/3HVOZ7HIY4ESC1.

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Company
ARTICLESHIP 14 November 2026
Article Assistant

Jitendra Agarwal & Associates

Bengaluru

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 18 November 2026
Articled Assistant

A.Singhi & Co

Kolkata

CA Inter

View Details
Company
16 November 2026
Assistant Article

ZAK & Co. Chartered Accountants

Bengaluru

CA Inter

View Details
Company
19 November 2026
Accounts & Taxation Executive

MCSR and Associates LLP

Hyderabad

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured 29 October 2026
Accounts Executive

Synergy Keystone

Chennai

B.Com

View Details
Company
10 November 2026
Direct Tax Manager

CAAQ CONSULTANCY PVT LTD

New Delhi

CA Final

View Details
Company
20 November 2026
Article

S & N CO

Mumbai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured ARTICLESHIP 31 October 2026
CA Articleship

apricus india

Navi Mumbai

CA Inter

View Details