LIVE GST Certification Course by CA Arun Chhajer begins 21st April. Register Now!!

New Final CA -Grand total 496 marks but Failed!!!!

Vignesh (Student) (30 Points)

21 January 2011

Dear all,

This is the first time I am writing on Caclub. Today I obtained my CA Final Results from November 2010.

It was a huge disappointment for me to see that I had secured 272 marks in Gr 1 (71+80+62+59) and 224 marks in Gr2 (77+23+53+71).

While I have satisfied the aggregate criteria on both groups and secured 496 marks(which I understand is the 37th ranker's total in India- congrats to him/her!), I have still failed Gr 2 because of ISCA 23 marks.

I am amazed at the variance in my marks as my aggregate besides ISCA is 68 odd. Do you think I should give for re-totaling. Seeking the advice of any seniors who may have had similar experiences.

Regards

Vignesh

Reply
Follow
Share

12 Replies

(Guest)

hii vignesh,

congrats for passing 1st grp.,

one of my friend is got ZERO mark in ICSA . He was sure that he will get atlesat 50 marks in this subject.

but he is very disappoint after seeing his result.

he wonder that how ICAI give ZERO marks in ICSA, also he was not absent in that paper . he was attend 80 mark paper.

.A.M. (Learner) (115 Points)
Replied 21 January 2011

I would suggest go for the retotal. I have heard that previously students were able to get increase of 20 to 30 marks on the retotal ! Good Luck.

Indigo (-) (533 Points)
Replied 21 January 2011

...hard..harsh result..sorry to hear... i feel u ll clear...plz go for retotal...i know u ll post in a fortnight time u cleared secured rank result.

vicky share ur preparation approach...books u followed so all ll be benefitted.

CA renuka Limaye (l & t) (61 Points)
Replied 21 January 2011

hey hello, really this tym results were shocking,i am to appear fr xams of final in may for first time,but one of my senior who was a rank holder at both levels of ca got aggregate total higher than u i.e. 509/800 bt failed in isca.this is really terrible.

ASGAR MEHDI SAIYED (STUDENT) (72 Points)
Replied 21 January 2011

wts ur roll no.???????

CA. Vikash Dwivedi (Financial Planning & Analysis) (3167 Points)
Replied 21 January 2011

Really Hard Luck... sure you should go for Retotaling.

At the same time i would suggest once you apply for Retotaling just forget ... means treat yourself as you are prepairing for May'11 (may be sounding hard but Sorry Dost).

In the past I secured 198 in First group and after retotaling i had toappear again. Likewise way back i secured 195 in Grup 2 & in the same exam 59 in IDT... retotaling didn't work in both case.

So Do apply for Retotaling ... but treat your self pass Only when you get your marksheet.

Common man CA mei hota hai... dont lose your heart

My best wishes for your Retotaling :-)

DEBATOSH KAMILA (CA FINAL Final Yr Article Trainee) (72 Points)
Replied 22 January 2011

OMG.. i m really shocked to hear ur result.. yup u can try for the retotalling.. hope u'll get pass..wish u good luck..

CA renuka Limaye (l & t) (61 Points)
Replied 23 January 2011

hey it is not my result.its my SENIOR BUDDY'S result.dnt remember roll no., n ya shes goin for re totalling

Payal K (CA FINAL) (188 Points)
Replied 24 January 2011

Can anyone suggest pattern of preparing for ISCA??

Dipu Divakar (Accountant) (70 Points)
Replied 24 January 2011

apply for retotaling.

Dipu Divakar (Accountant) (70 Points)
Replied 25 January 2011

i forgot to tell this thing yesterday. same thing happened last time ie for may 2010 attempt. one of my friend who also scored very high marks in all other subjects but failed in MICS and DT. i think she cleared DT that but couldnot score 60+ in DT. anyway she had to write only 2 papers is MICS and DT this november. and she cleared this time.

so i want to tell you that you apply for retotalling. pls dont expect a miracle, eventhough yout hink that are eligible for it.