ICAI Injustice

IPCC 3364 views 51 replies

Guest

I am here to tell you very interesting(unfortunate) incident of my friend which happened yesterday(I came to know today):

My friend had appeared for PCC exams in June 09, along with me.

A brilliant student he was, scored 346/600, but only scored 24 in IT/SM.

He was heartbroken,as he had to give costing/FM and IT/SM again (scored 63 in taxation).

He gave his IT/SM paper for rechecking and appeared his exams again.

When PCC results for Nov 09 were declared, his results were not found on website.

Mumbai office told him to enquire at Delhi. When he did so, yesterday the response came that he had cleared his exams in June 09 itself !!!

Institute had by mistake typed his IT/SM marks as 24 instead of 42 !

So now his June 09 marks go up to 364, which is extraordinary.

But now what about the 1 month leave he had taken to study? What about the 5 months extra stress he had to go through? What about the sadness his parents had to bear.

He was far successful than me then(I scored 341/600) , but his success wasnt sweet as mine...

Now how will ICAI compensate for it?

Replies (51)

Ashish M

Chartered Accountant

2731 Points Joined January 2008

I think ur friend should not sit on his back and accept the erring institute. He should file a letter to the president and ask for regularising the articleship period and add back the leave as regular articleship. Also, the same should also be brought to the notice of Board of studies....!!!!!!!!!!

CA LOVELY ARORA

C.A. B.Com (H) Graduate

2151 Points Joined August 2008

true injustice......... if it's real case...........

Dhanya Rose

Student

147 Points Joined September 2009

WOW... I can't blev this. We now understand that the dept of the ICAI that issues the admit cards has nothing to do with the dept releasing the results.

There seems to be some lack of internal coordination. Anyway. Wow. Poor friend of yours had to go through failure and the effort of going through applying again, studying again and all that.

All the best for final to both of you.

CA LOVELY ARORA

C.A. B.Com (H) Graduate

2151 Points Joined August 2008

yes, ashish is right............

Pradip Srinivasan

CA Final

869 Points Joined May 2009

Its better tat, the matter is taken to law. It may b a small error for inst, bt as a student it is nt so easy to accept it.

vipul

CA STUDENT

27 Points Joined May 2009

I think u should write to media for this unfare practice by th institute so that atleast for the next time they will be more careful about result.

shwetha

student

79 Points Joined December 2009

I think your friend should first write to the institute and ask them for compensating the articleship period for the leave taken and if the institute disagrees with him then its better to consult an advocate,file a petition and proceed accordingly. The institute should consider this issue seriously and compensate the student at any cost.

Guest

THANX FOR UR REPLIES...

WILL TELL MY FRIEND TO VIEW THIS POST FOR SUPPORT....!!

Amruta Shewale

Student CA FINAL

298 Points Joined August 2009

i dont believe. pls give his roll no. for nov 09 attempt we will check out

Guest

Originally posted by : Amruta Shewale
	i dont believe. pls give his roll no. for nov 09 attempt we will check out

its no use....

The site says" Roll No. not found.Please try again"

& anyways, had it been my no., i would have given it....but why to risk my friend?

Vikas Kumar Manjhi

Manager Finance Transformation

622 Points Joined December 2008

Firstly Congratulations To Both Of You Specially To Your Friend. You Must Put His June & November 2009 Roll Number To The Thread So That This Kind Of Mess-up May Be Made Public And No Other Student Has To Go Through Any Thing Like This...

You Should File An Application To The Board Of Studies And Ask The Reason For Such Big Mess-Up And Should Compensate Your Friend In Terms Of His Loss Of Articleship Period

ICAI Must Accept Their Mistake In Their Monthly Journal And Give Him A Public Apology In The Same..

Vikas Kumar Manjhi

Manager Finance Transformation

622 Points Joined December 2008

CA P.Vasudeva Rao

B.Com ACA

88 Points Joined March 2009

Originally posted by : Pradip Srinivasan
	Its better tat, the matter is taken to law. It may b a small error for inst, bt as a student it is nt so easy to accept it.

Yes, Pradip Srinivasan is correct. First you have to apply Institute for compensation for study holidays. If Institute reject the application, you may apply for CONSUMER COURT.

Rupesh Maheshwari

ACA Dip. IFR (ACCA)

6166 Points Joined November 2007

the matter should be referred to court.........its not just an error or mistake..........its a question of someone's career n life at large ..........the victim must be compensated at once