Icai concerns on dtc

ICAI expresses its concern on the proposed definition of “Accountant” in DTC, 2013 - (17-04-2014)


As the members are aware, the Direct Taxes Code, 2013 has proposed to widen the scope of the definition “Accountant” to include other professionals as well. It is a fact that various provisions in the Income-tax Act, 1961 under which chartered accountants have been given the responsibilities to undertake audit and certification of accounts of various entities have the emphasis on “audit” of the relevant accounts which is the exclusive domain of Chartered Accountants. 

The Council of ICAI is aware that the proposed change is a cause of major concern to the entire profession. In this regard, ICAI has through a representation to Ministry of Finance, placed on record its concern not only for the profession, but for the country as a whole since issuance of audit certificates by persons having limited knowledge of audit of accounts will not only be professionally incorrect and but will raise many concerns including causing huge revenue leakages. 

A meeting in this regard was held with Mr. Rajiv Takru, Revenue Secretary and Mr. R.K.Tewari, Chairman, CBDT on 16.4.2014, wherein CA. K. Raghu, President, ICAI and CA. Manoj Fadnis, Vice President, ICAI emphasized on the fact that there is a very significant difference in the area of expertise of other professionals vis-a-vis Chartered Accountants. 

Members be assured that the Council of ICAI is equally concerned and will not leave any stone unturned to save the profession and the nation. 
 

Secretary, Direct Taxes Committee
Replies (3)

HOW CAs ARE CLAIMING THAT THE OTHER PROFESSIONALS HAVE LIMITED KNOWLEDGE  WITH REGARD TO TAXATION AND AUDIT? IT IS UNFAIR TO UNDERESTIMATE THE OTHER PROFESSIONALS.  EVEN THE NON-PROFESSIONALS HAVE BETTER KNOWLEDGE AND EXPERTISE IN AUDITAND TAXATION.THAN CAs.

I THINK THERE SHOULD BE LEVEL PLAYING FIELD  FOR ALL THE PROFESSIONALS ( INCLUDING LEGAL PROFESSIONALS) AND THE BUSINESS COMMUNITY SHOULD HAVE FREEDOM TO SELECT PROFESSIONALS.

 

I dont think the issue here is level playing field. This would be like saying - a patient should have freedom to choose either a cardiac surgeon or a gyneacologist to do his open heart surgery.

The issue here is core competence. What would be a CMA's reaction if some act were to say that both CS' and CA's are also allowed to issue cost audit reports? or for that matter if CA's and CMA's were allowed to issue secretarial compliance reports?

It is part of the core training that Taxes Accounting and Audit are the core areas of the CA curriculum. The authorities need to respect this.

But the moot question is respect must be commanded and not demanded!!??!!

Some people from other professional body such as CMA and CS, with experience, could do a better job than a CA in audit/taxation. However, the Act should maintain that audit/taxation job done by a CA shall be applicable and legit.
 

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Company
Featured 12 September 2026
Assistant Manager - Finance & Compliance

Naveen Fintech Pvt Ltd

Kolkata

CA Inter

View Details
Company
08 September 2026
Semi-Qualified Assitant

Subrahmanyam & Sivudu CA Firm

Hyderabad

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 16 September 2026
CA Article Trainee

SR BAGAI & Co.

New Delhi

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured 21 September 2026
Consultant - Reporting

Finrep Advisors LLP

Mumbai

CA

View Details
Company
20 September 2026
Semi Qualified CA

Navin & Associates

Mumbai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 01 September 2026
Articles

Saini Pati Shah & Co LLP, Chartered Accountants

Mumbai

CA Foundation

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 15 September 2026
Freelance Taxation Content Writer Intern

Interactive Media Pvt Ltd.

New Delhi

CA Inter

View Details
Company
04 September 2026
CA inter Or ca finalist

A Jaiswal and company

Lucknow

CA Final

View Details