2 Points
Joined March 2026
Hi Amit,
I completely understand your point. Logically, it feels like a lost opportunity to save on taxes, and from an investor's perspective, your argument makes perfect sense!
However, the Income Tax Act operates on a strict sequence of computation rather than what is most tax-efficient. Here is the legal breakdown of why it works this way:
Mandatory Set-Off First (Section 70): The law requires you to aggregate all incomes and losses under the same head before calculating tax. You cannot choose to skip offsetting your Long Term Capital Loss (LTCL) against your Long Term Capital Gain (LTCG). It is a mandatory first step.
Exemption is a Threshold (Section 112A): The ₹1.25 Lakh limit is not a standard deduction you can claim at will. It is simply the threshold above which tax is levied.
The calculation strict order:
Gross LTCG: ₹1.25 Lakh
Less Current Year LTCL: (₹2.00 Lakh)
Net Capital Gain: ₹0 (with ₹75,000 carried forward)
Since your Net LTCG is zero, there is no gain left to apply the ₹1.25 Lakh exemption to. You don't "lose" the exemption; you simply didn't reach the taxable threshold this year because your losses absorbed the gains first.
Hope this makes the mechanics clearer, even if the outcome isn't what we'd hope for!