LIVE GST Certification Course by CA Arun Chhajer begins 27th April. Register Now!!

Give ur views on prawn feed question in IDT

pulkit gupta (CA final student) (160 Points)

16 May 2011

Please give your opinion regarding prawn feed question in IDT question paper.

Question in brief- Whether import of eggs which are intended as food for prawns is classifiable as prawn feed or goods ineligible for human question. Facts of the case- after some time larva comes out of the egg which is fed to prawns.

Does this question has anything to do with any of the provisions of the act or rules.

Reply
Follow
Share

20 Replies

chandar (Deputy Manager-Accounts) (296 Points)
Replied 16 May 2011

yes there is a case law regarding the same case.

MOHIT MAHAJAN (LCS, ACA) (2050 Points)
Replied 16 May 2011

Its related to classification of product, u will find the case in suggested case book of institute Alfred engineering pvt. ltd

kisna (student) (182 Points)
Replied 17 May 2011

its case on "Atherton Engineering" case. U can find it in Student Newsletter or RTP november, 2010 old syllabus. I wrote it.

pulkit gupta (CA final student) (160 Points)
Replied 17 May 2011

I know this question is related to classification & a particular case law. But my point is questions should be such that students should be able to answers by applying the rules & provisions. This question is so peculiar that it cant be answered unless the student has seen case law. This case law is of no general use, how many does deal in Brime shrimp eggs???

CS,CA F,Numrologi TusharSampat (CS CA F Numerologist Astrologer Graphologist Face reader Vastu Expert) (85930 Points)
Replied 17 May 2011

It std responsibilty to get himself of updated cases, circulars & notification.

Our President, VP etc are sreaming a lot via news letter n suc other media to std abt updation of our kno to be updated.

Further this paper is more of clarity of concepts......u cant blam ICAI on suc issues, whn its already askd frm their prntd bk "Selected Cases on Direct & Indirect Case 2010.....Hope thier mssg is communicated.

pulkit gupta (CA final student) (160 Points)
Replied 17 May 2011

Can u please tell me whats the use of grasping case laws. the institute shuld try to test the concept clarity & ability of the students to interpret the provisions, instead of testing their grasping powers. If u do not agree then please tell me what u learned from brime egg case.

CS,CA F,Numrologi TusharSampat (CS CA F Numerologist Astrologer Graphologist Face reader Vastu Expert) (85930 Points)
Replied 17 May 2011

They have q whic is logical ...evn if u don remeber d nam of case law bt u answrd on d basis of ur knowldg correctly thy would max deduct 1 mark n ull get 4/5.

ur d stud of ICAI n nt d vice versa......so don blam icai....u hve decide to do CA n appear for FInal exm n nt icai forcd u to appear for tht............exm...

y ru so muc worried on 1 q ask by ICAI

Wats d use of arguing on issues whic ICAI wll nver consider n niethr ull gain ny thing frm suc war of words

so u concentrate on wat icai's says n does.......fr studnts.....

Mayank Ahuja ("Learner") (586 Points)
Replied 17 May 2011

Answer is Classified Under Heading2309

pulkit gupta (CA final student) (160 Points)
Replied 17 May 2011

Originally posted by : TusharSSampatM.Com CA,CS-FINAL
	They have q whic is logical ...evn if u don remeber d nam of case law bt u answrd on d basis of ur knowldg correctly thy would max deduct 1 mark n ull get 4/5. ur d stud of ICAI n nt d vice versa......so don blam icai....u hve decide to do CA n appear for FInal exm n nt icai forcd u to appear for tht............exm... y ru so muc worried on 1 q ask by ICAI Wats d use of arguing on issues whic ICAI wll nver consider n niethr ull gain ny thing frm suc war of words so u concentrate on wat icai's says n does.......fr studnts.....

Tushar, u r still not understanding what i am saying. dont act as if u are very loyal towards the institute and I am acting like a complaining student. Pls just answer my simple question what learned from that case.

CS,CA F,Numrologi TusharSampat (CS CA F Numerologist Astrologer Graphologist Face reader Vastu Expert) (85930 Points)
Replied 17 May 2011

I learned that ans is classified under the heading 2309

shivali bardoliya (Articled Assistant) (42 Points)
Replied 17 May 2011

If u have any doubt abt that que then i kindly request u to refer to the case laws book of the institute for may,2011 exams. U will get answer of ur question.

Sriram (CA FINAL) (126 Points)
Replied 17 May 2011

Originally posted by : pulkit gupta
	Please give your opinion regarding prawn feed question in IDT question paper. Question in brief- Whether import of eggs which are intended as food for prawns is classifiable as prawn feed or goods ineligible for human question. Facts of the case- after some time larva comes out of the egg which is fed to prawns. Does this question has anything to do with any of the provisions of the act or rules.

Kisna has answered it perfectly.... It is Atherton Engineering Co Pvt Ltd (2010) case law... That case is available in Selected Cases book released by the institute relevant for May & Nov 2011 examinations... some more cases will be added for this applicable for nov 2011 exam & which will be published in ICAI web site by the end of JULY 2011.... check it out...

(Guest)

Re Pulkit,

Did you got anything by mugging up the due dates ..........certainly nothing more than marks because due dates will change in the coming Finance Act......... but you wrote them to earn marks......same is the case with case laws..........hope you got your answer.