LIVE GST Audit Course by CA Sachin Jain. Register Now!!

Dt t n manorahan

krishan agrawal (student) (324 Points)

19 February 2012

is manorahan sufficient or should i use another book with it like vk singhania.please help and someone please tell the imp chapters and strategy to clear this subject.

Reply
Follow
Share

12 Replies

Joy (Student ) (92 Points)
Replied 19 February 2012

In my opinion, TN Manoharan's book is useful for Theory and is intended for quick revision before exam. However Singhania's Book is better for solving the tax numerical problems. So what you can do is study the concepts and fundas of taxation from Manoharan and apply those concepts while solving the numericals from Singhania. I hope that my reply was helpful. https://www.csjournal.in

krishan agrawal (student) (324 Points)
Replied 19 February 2012

then in your opinion i should buy vk or vinod gupta is preferable does it contains good amount of problems talking abt vinod gupta i have used vk in pcc as well as manorahan

(Guest)

Go for T N Manoharan. Its a typical xam oriented book. Moreover select the book which u will b able to finish in a day, during xams. N stick to any 1 book per subject. More books will create more confusion rather than any value addition.

1 Like

krishan agrawal (student) (324 Points)
Replied 19 February 2012

dear ketan do i need to purchase another book for problems bcause manorahan doesnt have adequate no of problems

krishan agrawal (student) (324 Points)
Replied 19 February 2012

thanks joy n ketan for your replies

(Guest)

The no. of problems in T N Manoharan are more than enough. Just solve them. I also stuck to T N Manoharan n got 60 in DT. Also refer practice manual by ICAI.

krishan agrawal (student) (324 Points)
Replied 19 February 2012

thanks for clearing my doubt and can u tell how to study means which chapter to begin with and strategy to clear dt also will you suggest about idt chapter preference and books to follow if you can suggest for costing and isca it would be great help for me.thanks

(Guest)

check ur pm.

CA Deepak Rathore (CA) (223 Points)
Replied 20 February 2012

CA. Ketan Kr G Saha ,

Sir, Please share your suggestion here if u don't have any porblem, becasue that may be helpfull for other students like me.

(Guest)

For DT- divide the syllabus into two parts- syllabus till PCC/IPCC i.e. heads of income & computation & basic concepts and rest of final. Before starting final syllabus u need to have conceptual knowledge of PCC syllabus. For IDT- finish VAT & Service Tax then customs & then excise. For Costing & ISCA- practice manuals by ICAI & for ISCA module. All the BEst. If u have any query reply.

2 Like

Back in the Game (a) (1273 Points)
Replied 20 February 2012

I had referred TN manoharan for pcc.it just states the provision ,i want a book which apprecaites intention of law maker.i mean gives an idea why law is framed so tat conceptual clarrity can be attained...

is there any such book?

santhosh Kumar (CA) (129 Points)
Replied 25 February 2012

I agree with ketan kumar ... the flow is good and you can revise the entire chapter before exams.. more over in DT you need to get to know the act rather than doing the numerical problems..