Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman's announcement at the 56th GST Council meeting that GST on individual health and life insurance premiums will drop from 18% to 0% starting September 22, 2025, has brought relief to policyholders. However, tax experts caution that the extent of savings will depend on a crucial technical distinction, whether premiums are classified as nil-rated or exempt.
Nil-Rated vs Exempt: Why It Matters
"Nil-rated supplies are taxable at 0% GST, which still allows insurers to claim input tax credit (ITC). Exempt supplies, however, lie outside GST and block insurers from availing ITC," explained a tax expert.
The classification could directly affect insurance premiums because ITC helps insurers offset GST paid on operating expenses such as rent, IT services, and agent commissions. Without ITC, these costs could feed back into higher premiums for customers.
The Cost Impact
Under the earlier system, insurers charged 18% GST on premiums but could claim ITC, keeping tax costs neutral. With exemption, that balance changes.
- Earlier (with ITC): On a Rs 100 premium, if insurers incurred Rs 5.4 GST on costs, they could claim it back.
- Now (if exempt): The same Rs 5.4 GST becomes unrecoverable. To maintain margins, insurers may increase premiums by 5-6%.
One tax professional added that for every Rs 50 of expenses attracting 18% GST (Rs 9), insurers lose this ITC under exemption. "This could push a Rs 100 premium up to Rs 109," he said.
SAHIs May Bear the Brunt
Standalone health insurers (SAHIs) are seen as particularly vulnerable since they lack taxable product lines like motor or fire insurance to offset ITC losses.
"Nearly 30% of insurers' operating costs attract GST," said a tax advisor. "Retail health premiums could rise by 5-6%."
Another expert warned of sharper increases: "SAHIs might face hikes of 12-18% if premiums remain exempt rather than NIL-rated."
Industry Seeks Clarity
Insurers and industry associations are pressing the GST Council to classify these premiums as NIL-rated to preserve ITC flow. A final clarification is expected in the coming weeks.
Until then, while the zero-GST announcement is positive, the real benefit to policyholders hinges on the technical decision between nil-rated and exempt.
CAclubindia
