WHY ICWAI IS LEFT BEHIND........

Feedback 1682 views 3 replies

 

The government plans to redefine the functions of the National Advisory Committee on Accounting Standards (Nacas) to convert it into an independent regulatory entity to monitor the quality of audit undertaken across the corporate sector in the country.

The proposal, made by the corporate affairs ministry to the Parliamentary Committee on Finance that looked into the Companies Bill, 2009, says the revamped Nacas should be allowed to oversee and monitor the performance of standard setting bodies for the accountancy and audit professions.

Autonomous institutions such as the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) and the Institute of Company Secretaries of India, under the administrative control of the corporate affairs ministry, are the standard setting bodies for accountancy and audit professions.

The ministry response came after the Parliamentary committee, which submitted its report last week, expressed concerns over the global economic crisis and the failure of big companies and suggested the formation of an independent regulator to recommend standards for corporate financial reporting, corporate audit and the quality of service of professionals associated with ensuring compliance with such standards. It also wanted this body to oversee, monitor and supervise the bodies involved in setting such standards.

Replies (3)

good question. may i know where it was published? some newspaper publish like that......

ICAI who is  Accounting Regulator of India, say..........

they have to inform by ICWAI that ICAI is not accounting regulator of India as accounting include cost accounting as well and for which there is ICWAI.

To become Associate member of ICAI, passing of Final exam of CA is sufficient by satisfying article ship .The three years period of article is considered as three years of experience and Associate ship is given in ICAI.

But , if you consider ICWAI the associate membership will be given if the candidate passes Final course of ICWAI and possesses three years of responsible experience. Definitely becoming Associate of ICWAI is difficult and worthy compared to three years of articles experience.

If we compare the required three years of experience for Associate Membership in ICAI and ICWAI
(a) In case of Articles of ICAI specific responsibility is not fixed on person (student) , but in case of ICWAI ( the candidate is mostly employee) the three years of experience is in a job where job responsibility is fixed.
(b) most of the times, in ICWAI the person works and deals in the system of an industry where management practices and finance functionals are present and he learns industry, management and finance practices.
(c ) The article ship experience is an experience gained as a student , i.e. . Normally understanding or working with half or zero knowledge(they are beginers in learning). In case of ICWAI the three years of experience is with in job responsibility . If it is experience as semi qualified of fully qualified , then it is the experience gained with sound subject understanding.

So in case of ICWA , the knowledge gained is more worthy and sound. The depth and scope of learning is more before becoming Associate Member in ICWAI compared to CA.

For better quality in education and knowledge , ICWAI should not think about introducing article ship in its course.

ICAI ALSO SHOULD SERIOUSLY RE-THINK ABOUT ITS ARTICLES AND PROCEDURE OF ASSOCIATE MEMBERSHIP . IT SHOULD EITHER AVOID ARTICLES OR SHOULD FOLLOW THE PRACTICES OF ICWAI FOR ASSOCIATE MEMBERSHIP.

Please read the following two links without fail.

1. /forum/icwa-articleship-training-vs-ca-articleship-training-81612.asp?1=1&offset=1

2. https://cmaindia.informe.com/forum/icwai-chapters-f148/again-and-again-discuss-ca-vs-cma-the-facts-t3736.html
 

wahhh wahhh!

Zalim ne kalam me kitna dard bhar k likha hai...

Alrite, jokes appart.... Please specify the Orignal source so professionals can express their view.


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Company
Featured 14 March 2026
Associate CA

N N V Satish&co

Hyderabad

CA

View Details
Company
Featured 19 March 2026
Article Assistant

Gupta Sachdeva & Co. Chartered Accountants

New Delhi

CA Final

View Details
Company
Featured 14 April 2026
GST CONSULTANT

Abhishek G Agrawal & Co.

Korba

CA Final

View Details
Company
Featured 14 March 2026
Article Trainee

N N V Satish&co

Hyderabad

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured 13 April 2026
GST CONSULTANCY

Abhishek G Agrawal & Co.

Korba

CA Final

View Details
Company
Featured 28 March 2026
Accountant

Ashok Amol & Associates

New Delhi

B.Com

View Details
Company
Featured 28 March 2026
CA Final

Ashok Amol & Associates

New Delhi

CA Final

View Details
Company
Featured 12 March 2026
Customer Relationship Executive

TAXLET

Calicut

B.Com

View Details