I personally believe that everyone has right to question..
Komal has too... if she is not fake.. its okay..
We have no right to judge other until we are perfect..
Even no right to judge the profession..
We all are in favour of CA because we belong to that..
Next we are also in favour of MBA... 
Because we know every profession has its own dignity..
People here commenting because they respect their
profession.. they cant see it being insulted..
Like nobody can see insulting own parents by others..
My profession has same place as my parents are in my life...
That is what we all are conveying..

Next to excel in everything is quite not possible sometimes...
So everything has its own limitations...
But if we just perceive the negative side, then this is like
cutting the branch of tree on which we are sitting..

Why MBA are more brilliant.. its not about MBA... its about the
person who is MBA.. and he knows how to handle the 
situation... I must say this is human psychology..
not about profession..

CA is distance eduction not like "MBA.. a regular college"..
ICAI always try to possible to make learning better.. 
Even distance MBA does not provide such better learning..
Yes it was the time when CAs were lack in communication 
and presentation... but today... scenerio has changed...

Just want to say... if you really in favour of MBA..
please try to maintain your professionalism.."
Yes you've right to put up Question..
But dont create the mess... I respect your thoughts..
But you should respect us too... We are your friend 
dear... not enemy...

This thread will be stopped from any further comments........

(pretty soon)..............

(by the admin)

Why CA doing students are not that good in communication and presentation when compared to MBA doing students??

Lack of communication & presentation skills in CA students as compared to MBA students may be less because CA students have less exposure in making presentations, courses like GMCS help to overcome that deficiency.

Why most of the CA doing students particularly girls look very average compared to MBA doing Students??

Irrelevant question. Looks cannot tell you about a persons capabilities. One should not judge a book by its cover. Money can buy you good looks but not everyone belongs to a rich family.

Why CA students fumble while arguing with MBA qualified students.?? ?

It depends on what the discussion (argument) is about. A CA can make any person fumble Big time ( an MBA too) just depends on what is being discussed (argued).

Why CA students work like a clerk even after qualifying the final level??

What do you mean by ' work like a clerk ' please explain?

The quality of work given to a person depends on the capabilities of that person. No organisation would employ people lacking the skills & knowledge required for the job be it a CA or an MBA or an Engineer. The quality of work depends on the quality of the person. The profession can't be blamed.

Why most of the CA's could not take business decisions unlike MBA's??

which CA's could not take business decisions unlike MBA's?
was it within the CA's responsibilities to take business decisions?

You should know that CA's are consulted for Major business decisions like Acquisition & mergers, etc.

It all depends on the nature of the job. I Dont agree that a CA who is responsible for making a business decision wont be able to do it.

I heard about the topper.... These kind of students are also one the reason why CA's dont excel
 in communication and presentation...

That was a very unprofessional statement & was uncalled for.

Why did a student from a vernac. medium secure an all India Rank & not a student from an english medium outdo her performance may I ask?
Knowing a language does not mean possessing knowledge. Her knowledge & skills compensate for her lack of quality of english. She can learn english with time its not a hurdle for life & it in no way belittles her capabilities.

And even your language skills are not very high according to what I observed from your conversations. Before you start calling me a pervert too let me clear that it's just an Observation that I made. Please think for a minute before you speak something about a person.

I hope I have answered your questions to your satisfaction.

i felt a few things after reading these posts..

1. a real professional or a wannabe pro wont think or discuss or compare his pro wid others. i feel he should focus on the opportunities available to him and utilise the maximum skills.

2. why should people make so much useless fights and discussion. Neither the icai president nor the CCI admin wont solve this query.

Pls put an end to this discussion as it seems going nowhere.

PS:- just said wat i felt. nothing meant to hurt anyone.

@ Urvashi

u r right in saying that each of us should respect other's profession......me or anybody here does not intend to disrespect MBA as profession....and u r also right that it depends upon the person and not the profession...but all thses advice are falling on deaf ears...these people komal caclub member wont understand...coz they jst dont want to ....dey jst want to win the arguement....be it by putting useless agruements or gaining sympathy by citing personal attacks which was initiated by them only....

so i request to leave these two in their misconceptions....by replyimg on this useless post we r just giving them the publicity that they dont desreve...

so its just a request to ignore them....u r my frnd thats m suggesting u... 

even i want this thread to be deleted...

Plz Stop all that fighting...

Originally posted by : Richa
	even i want this thread to be deleted...

uhh... Then please send a pm to the admin.......

(everyone who wants this to be deleted)

to whom do i have to send the pm

@ Richa: Go to your inbox. And there at the left side, you can see an option for sending pm to the admin!

@ ca club member

actualy for ur information ...big corporates dont employ dumb and stubborn ppl like u and miss komal who despite so much expalnation are not even ready to accept anything leave wat to sy about getting convinced...'its not about winning or losing here...its no debate going on in which winner will be rewarded...

want it thread to be deleted coz d discussion going on is of no use.....jst entertainment for u n komal

n dont u worry abt me...i know how to handle ppl and situatons...and where to draw the line...

i read sumwhere that to convince a bevkoof u will have to go down to their level....and sorry i cant come to that girl's level...so better i leave...

@ CA CLUB MEMBER

WHY YOU ARE TRYING TO RAISE THE CONVERSATION AGAIN

SAY ONE USE OF THIS CONVERSATION

Respected CCI Members,

I urge everyone to kindly restrain from posting comments after comments on this thread, as it seems that the originator is less than a week old with this ID in the Forum and has made very derogatory and controversial statements about some of the members.

I did not wanted to give comments, before verifying some facts, so I checked the profile of the author of this thread and found some obnoxious and personal ego emanating in the post. I never wanted to make it personal but a person who passes senseless comments about individuals; we should IGNORE them, as they do not have any credibility to oppose others when they themself are not perfect.