quantitative aptitude

CPT 727 views 11 replies

can anybody answer this

 it is given that a family of 2 children  has a girl, what is the probablity that the other child is also a girl ?

they hav given it as 1/3 ? can anybody explain me ?

Replies (11)

answer is wrong....it will be 1/2....or i think the question is not complete....check it...and in the book many answers were given wrong....

1/3 is the correct answer.

since there are 2 boys and 1 girl,the  boy and girl ratio is 2:1, which implies that  the probability of the fourth child being a girl is 1/3 , that is one girl among three childes.

however if we take the example of a coin then the probability of getting a tail or head is always 1/2, which is unaffected by previous results, according to this principle the answer should be 1/2, since both the problems are identical, but remember the outcome in case of child birth is not definite, there can be even 2 boys or 2 girls i,e twin births !!! there have been cases where count goes even higher !!!

So I strongly go with the first answer, that is, the probability of 1/3 is the correct answer.


Agree with wasi Khan

What you people think about the question and its answer?

in the question it is given that , the family of two children has a girl , on the assumption that family of 2 children has only one child each, (girl) , then the probablity of other child is also a girl is 0.50 .but from your point of view 1/3 is correct . then what vl be the answer if this same question appears in the cpt? 1/3 or 0.50

 

thank you friends

Well, the answer should be 1/2... I answered it thinking there are 3 childrens in the family,however there are only two of opposite genders. So the answer should be 1/2 and the answer given in the book might be wrong as pointed out by Sneha.

i think the probablity that the another child is girls is 1/2 ,,,,,,,

the answer should be 1/2 of the this question.


In your case either the question or the answer is wrong in the book

I will go for 1/2. Even if in a family there are 9 girls and 1  boy according to me probability of having a boy or girl will be 1/2 each just like a toss of coin..!! 

i agree with sneha Answer of this is 1/2

thank you friends


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register