Negative aspect of CA

CA 3828 views 39 replies

I never thought that I’d ever  feel the need to write such article. I really hate the word “CA” ….. In fact I  used to think what really made me choose CA …. Obviously as I couldn’t find out the real answer so the interest in studies also reduced by itself. But when I had joined CA club last year, I had seen many people are also sailing in the same boat and asking the question why ?  As the time passed, with good friends motivation  and discussion , when my thoughts got changed, I couldn’t even realizeenlightened. People used to share their experience whether positive or negative which really encourage others to do their best from the bottom of heart.heart

But from some days, I am continuously noticing that something  is really going wrong. People are creating  such posts which leaves skeptics in the mind of others who are in the journey of doing CA. They are continuously cursing CA  for such reasons as :

  1.  Failure : -   Constant failures are simply a time waste. Struck in  CA for 5 years is really a tough cookie and facing the hardships of life is also a part of it. You can do an MBA or something else which can be finished in less time and even bearing fruits.  Reallysurprise !!!

Is that the real option to choose ….Because there can be nothing worse than leaving something in half. Especially when you choose the second option because you had tasted the defeat….Well, I don’t even oppose the reason that if you want to be risk manager and struck at CA , then switching between the course won’t affect you, as CA is not your real aim… but if defeat is the real reasonof leaving CA… then definitely it’s not a right choice. Because while dreaming something you don’t think how much efforts would be put into achieving  the same … dreams are made with the flow of imaginations, a journey of enjoying the ups and downs and finally  feeling  the pride in achieving the same. angel

 

If you can dream whatever I said , then there is no meaning to look back and doubt your option.angel And asking yourself if failure a sign to quit … !!!!

 

 

  1.  Job guarantee : - OMG ….  There is no difference between a CA and  a graduate.  You can do the job just right after your  graduation and  earn easily. You can easily hear such examples  i.e.  CWA gives even more practical exposure,  MBA’s have good communication and  practical skills. Well, if you are really asking this question …..Then I want to say the famous Gulshan Kumar ( T-series creator)  was a vegetable sellercool.  It means  then you don’t need a degree to be successful. Then why just cursing the CA degree alone….broken heart

In my arena, I have lots of frns who have done CA . Some of them are rankholders, passed in 1st attempt and some are even who passed their finals in 3-4 attempts. They all got the jobs easily due to their skills. They are earning a good salary as well.  They also faced some questions which they couldn’t answer but still it doesn’t mean that they are not worthy enough.   Being true to yourself not only increase the confidence in your own but also  helps in conceiving  the other one that you are surely the right one person for whom the interviewer was really looking for.mail

 

I don’t say that constant improvement is not needed.Be sure that whatever and from wherever knowledge you acquire, is the best one.

 

  1.  Classes/ self study : -  I don’t know how can anyone really question about  the mode of study. Taking coachings  are a waste of time. You don’t learn anything. But  just tell me, if a person is able  to understand everything by him/herself then why he/she would  waste his money in  coachings. 

Thousands amount invested in coachings by many students are not fooling themselves.It’s a hope that they will surely improve themselves.What’s the meaning in criticizing the same option …

 

Well this question is also faced by those persons who prefer to do self study.Self study means you’ll be struggling for more hours, giving more attempts, less marks …. It’s not a good option in any way. Excuse me !!!!

 

If a person chooses the self study mode , then obviously kuch soch ke hi kiya hoga …… !!!! Even a kid knows that ifhe would touch the fire, he will be burnt. Then a person who is doingself study obviously knows the pros and cons of doing the same.

 

What’s the meaning of creating the doubt that you won’t get real knowledge.And if a person doesn’t get real knowledge by doing his/her articleship, self study or coaching mode….. Then from where he can really learn those  things ….. surprise

 

Everybody doesn’t know everything buteveryone knows something.

 

It takes time to learn and persistence and preservation of knowledge comes with experience.Let those people learn by themselves and find what could work best for them.

 

 

Conclusion:-

 

Taking criticism as a grain of saltisalways a best option. A person can change everything if he values his/her efforts and still expect them to take it up a notch.yesenlightened

 

 

Note :-

I was walking on eggshells while writing this. But still if I've  hurt someone with my thoughts, then I'm really sorry for this.

 

Regards

Renu

 

Replies (39)

Everyone in this Course like Faculty / Managment of ICAI say this from Student Point of View but No one Says from Institute's point of view while disinterest in this Course of students is mainly due to Institute's 60 years Old Pattern of Study..there is nothing change in Course Structure/ Training pattern..

great job renu ji.............

for your kind information Renu Singh

Everyone in this Course like Faculty / Managment of ICAI say this from Student Point of View but No one Says from Institute's point of view while disinterest in this Course of students is mainly due to Institute's 60 years Old Pattern of Study/ practical Training...Today also 60 years Old Pattern of Study/ practical Training is running...Institute has no more focus on Student,, now institute's is focusing on earning aspect only... that is not best for coming day/// what's position of Coming Chartered Accountant Students is not known to every one... 

I don't agree with it ...

just tell me ... have u ever attend any seminar  hold by ICAI at times ...for example revised sch VI ...

how can anyone say so easily that what you are doing is simply a crap .... crying

@ Renu No Professional course or any equivalent degree provides job guarantee today, if you are a CA CS CWA student you should concentrate on ur studies while gathering the practical knowledge.. If you know how to tackle the customers n the key areas to perform Big Co. are ready to offer handsome packages what you always dreamed of.. Rumours are always been part of CA course its not a new phenomenon..

Like it, as its something different or say the things running in the mind of all students may be not at every moment but surely on occasions these questions run through mind.

Some analysis from mecool

Coaching vs self study,

A considerable part of students are going for coaching, though its not everything or last option but definitely its the game changer and helpful option.

But the people opting for self study are also not wrong at their place, may be they are self confident and powerful enough to grasp the things easly then others or may be their condition is not allowing for coachings. But I guess they gain more knowledge then the people who are going for coaching.

CA vs Other Courses,

Well, without any debate, I would say CAs are capable to do more task with expertise then any other fields people (Definitely exceptions are there).

And in last,

Come on yaar cool its still one course which gives you job gurantee with good pay but the condition is you have learned the skills honestly in articleship.yes

Thanks & regards,

Abhi

Renu Singh first tell me how many seminar on Rev. Sch. VI conducted by ICAI in Uttar Paradesh //////

yes Aryan ...I truly agree with your viewpoint.

That nothing in this world can guarantee a perfect Job.... chahe wo person koi sa bi profession opt kar le.

 

 

Constant improvement in one self is essential in every part of life smiley

Originally posted by : sachit kumar
Renu Singh
first tell me how many seminar on Rev. Sch. VI conducted by ICAI in Uttar Paradesh //////


I belong to delhi ... So I have clue about only vishwas nagar.

There would also be seminars there too in noida ...as the same is  headoffice of ICAI

@ Sachit,

Which kind of changes do you want from ICAI? Pease give suggestions so we can discuss on that.

Thanks.

However, nowadays students are opting towards CA course without knowing the hell of Chartered Accountancy.. You can ask a CA Cpt/IPCC student what does the word 'Chartered' stands for in the content of Chartered Accountancy? 8 out of 10 will have no ans.. It doesn't mean they are not good or not capable of doing CA, they are but they will create the entire scenario incomplete.. Having no practical knwlge,no burden of self study,availability of notes,tuitions,pirated classes.. And lastly ICAI introduces the direct entry plan "sone pe suhaga" nothing can be worse than that..

hey Renu 

I salute you for encourage to CA Students.... but which you said, it is best for MetroPolian Student // and all metropolian students says this// but which i said it is a matter which require big discussion of Institute on which institute again and again on backfoot like BJP....

I am also part of this institute...and also respect for this.... but Truth is always truth..

thanks

hello Mr. Abhimanyu

first & big point is Study Material...

@ Sanchit Orientation classes,GMCS are not prior period things, these programmes are originated for the sake of CA Students so we can compete against MBAs n othrs institutions.. CA course had changed a lot if you followed it thoroughly.. After Wales, Indian CAs are the most eligible candidates in the Finance field.


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register