Automation Expert
10728 Points
Posted on 13 November 2026
TCS on scrap is generally calculated on the sale consideration excluding GST, where GST is separately shown in the invoice. TCS under section 206C(1) is on the amount payable by the buyer; CBDT Circular No. 23/2017 clarifies that where GST is separately indicated, TDS is deducted on the amount excluding GST. Though that circular concerns TDS, the same treatment is generally followed for TCS. Accordingly, if the taxable value is ₹100 and GST is ₹18, TCS at 1% would ordinarily be ₹1, not ₹1.18.
- A mismatch may arise if the sale value reported and the TCS base used in the return are not aligned. Keep the invoice, ledger and return workings consistent, and report the sale and TCS figures in the applicable fields as prescribed.
- If an officer disputes exclusion of GST, the department could raise a demand for short collection, with applicable interest and potentially penalty proceedings, depending on the facts and the provision invoked. The circular provides a supportable basis for excluding separately stated GST, but it is a TDS clarification, not an express TCS clarification.
- Review the applicable contract and invoice presentation; where GST is not separately identifiable, the position may require closer examination.
For scrap-sale invoicing and TCS reconciliation, a consistent taxable-value basis helps prevent avoidable differences between invoices, ledgers and returns. Manual checking across transactions is difficult, and automation can reduce repetitive work while keeping professional judgment in control. Our platform offers 2,000+ AI agents and 650+ integrations covering only relevant workflows. To explore a workflow suited to your practice, you’re welcome to WhatsApp us at https://wa.me/message/3HVOZ7HIY4ESC1.