CA RESULTS- MY VIEW

Final 703 views 5 replies

well the CA results have been declared and I m going thru the various messages on this subject . I thought to put across my point of view as well.

There is no doubt that CA results  that have come out are probably the worst in the decade.

My observations for the poor results is as follows

1) Despite having relatively good results last time around only 47% got jobs in placement .

2) There may be only 1,60,000 CA and considering 10% are retired, 10% stay abroad and almost 20 % are in practise. so roughly 1 lac are there in industry . most students may argue that there should be great demand for CA professionals but reality is that CA have to compete against ICWA , MBA finance , CS, post graduates, diploma in finance in the crowded job market.

3) Besides at the lower level ie executive & AM level there is ever increasing no of graduates, CA inters, finalist etc that do up role . Thus dispensing the requirement of CA

4) Today Corporates have become extremely cost centric as they consider CA as cost centres not revenue generators.they consider finance & CA as support function which is necessity for regulatory and compliance purposes. SO they want the person in finance at low salaries.

 

 

Replies (5)

So they use mark reduction techniques and fail students.......... Instead of doing so they can stop conducting exams for few years................ Don think am angry yer....... I understand the logic behind but ultimately the students are the sufferers............... Anyways we are to face all such challenges and come up in life........... Cheeeeeeeeeers....................

Any ways good analysis buddy............

@ Vishal

i agree that there is very LIMITED demand n will always be LIMITED demand...i guess CA is tough slarynot justified its toughness....may 2010 results were worst....i guess ICAI should take LIMITED students at the begining rather taking taking over 50000 studetns through CPT.........ICAI becomes cash cow......

I personally feel...only those who want to practice should enter this field...so the question of demand and supply does not arise.....

Every person is self employed...so he makes his own market....he creates the demand for himself by giving g8 service....The sky is the limit for practice and even if there are 10 lakh CAs...there is still scope for self employment for all...We should focus more on how to improve ourselves and our diverse skills....We should develope are attitude for practice....We should remove the misconception that Practice is meant only for someone who has a base or someone who has g8 financials....Every Firm that is there in existence now...did at some point in time start from scartch through the hard way....

The entry shud be made even more stringent like the CAT exams....and the there has to be a radical change in the way articleship is done.....more focus shuld be made on how to make a student grow into setting up his own practice.....rather than making them like robots and do mechanical ...routine finacial work...

Originally posted by : Priya

So they use mark reduction techniques and fail students.......... Instead of doing so they can stop conducting exams for few years................ Don think am angry yer....... I understand the logic behind but ultimately the students are the sufferers............... Anyways we are to face all such challenges and come up in life........... Cheeeeeeeeeers....................

Agree with Vishal. Good analysis!!

A small addition to the above must be done regarding CPT students already grabbing little demand that is left for CA Final Students in future.

Many corporates are now definitely not relying on passing students rather experienced and fresh quantum. It is a broad mind that is taking over indian corporate thinking (thanks to MNC's) that they are now ready to rake risks over freshers including plain graduates rather CA's who still have hard luck in full-fledged exposure unless and untill a Big 4 material.

Time is really running out if we don't correct the ways things are going..bcoz in the end only students suffer not the benchmarks.


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register