AAR verdict on high sea sale

As per the below link, AAR verdict says GST on high sea sale of merchant trade transactions has to be levied as if it's interstate transaction and IGST applicable. Can someone provide insight into this? from when is this effective?

Link:

https://www.outlookindia.com/newsscroll/goods-purchased-sold-overseas-liable-to-gst-in-india-aar/1870001
Replies (5)
Quick Summary
The Authority for Advance Ruling (AAR) has determined that GST on high sea sales in merchant trade transactions should be treated as an interstate transaction, making IGST applicable. However, this ruling may only apply to periods before the amendment of Schedule III of the CGST Act. The amendment, effective from February 1, 2019, clarifies that merchant trading is neither a supply of goods nor services, potentially rendering the AAR's decision obsolete for current transactions.

Please refer amended schedule III of CGST act. it will solve your doubt. AAR is issued before amendment in law, hence, that advance ruling may be applicable only before the date of amendment in schedule III.
Yes Agree with
What about the recent Advance Ruling given by Gujarat Authority for Advance Ruling in the case of Sterlite Technologies Limited ???

They have ruled that GST would be applicable on Merchant Trading ???

Is this ruling absurd too ???
Yes undoubtedly. it completely ignores the amendment carried out in schedule III. interestingly, date of application is too old. may be they have arrived at solution for period prior to amendment.
As per Amendment Act , 31 of 2018 , the Merchant Trading being inserted under s.no.7 of Schedule III , effective from 1/2/2/19 , so it's. Neither the supply of Goods nor supply of Services.
Moreover in term of Section 103 of CGST , the advance ruling pronounced by the authority is applicable only on Applicant one who sought for It.

(M/s sterlite definately go for AAAR )

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register