44ad and its 5th provision

185 views 4 replies

RAMESH D MODI

Proprietor

4869 Points Joined January 2010

In case of a partnership, net profit for the f.y. 2016-17 is ZERO after allowing interest and remuneration to partners as per section 40 b.

1) Gross receipt 30 lac
2) expenses including purchase.
26 lac
3) interest and remuneration 4 lac
4) net profit 00
Is the firm required to get his books audited u/s 44ab as he is not having any income which is chargable to tax.
Section 44ad(5)

Replies (4)

Guest

In the second calculation, if the amount after deduction of Remuneration and Interest is a loss, will the audit be necessary?

Guest

Originally posted by : Madhavi Pandit
	In the second calculation, if the amount after deduction of Remuneration and Interest is a loss, will the audit be necessary?

No.

Because, the income should be more than the maximum amount not chargeable to tax, which would be zero for the firm.

What is your opinion about it ma'am?

Guest

IF we don't use ITR 4(sugam) I believe,we can claim remunertion and interest on capital resulting in loss and audit won't be necessary (since we are not opting for 44AD). I have to see if the ITR utility accepts this and hope that the return is not rendered defective later.

If this is not allowed,it would be highly unfair to those partnerswho don't have any incomeother than interest on capital & remuneration. The whole of book profit will be taxed @ 30% in firm's hands where actually the firm has paid salary to partners.

Converting it into proprietorship will be beneficial then.

More views are welcome.