submitted query on e-saayatha with icai

respected sirs ,
with due regards to the suggested answers issued by the institute for ca final (new) for november 2010 , there are some serious mistakes in paper 7  and paper 8 .
direct tax and indirect tax .
indirect tax :-  example :-
q.2.a  . view of the department is correct , however in emmllen biotech v. cce  2004 (163)elt 172 cegat , it had held that if cenvat cerdit wrongly taken us reversed before the issue of show cause notice , interest is not payable ., however institute suggested tells as :- yes the dept. is correct , interest is payable u/s 11AB if credit not utilize

again in direct tax :-  question no. 1.c. cirag's , value of flat is taken as rs. 3 lks rather than 5 lks
q.2.a.  why  rs. 4 lks speculative loss had been denied
q. 7.b  computation of net wealth of mr. ram
     as per institute suggested , answer is rs. 380 lks
    however the answer should be rs.90 lks , with reference to shivanarian chaudhari vs. cwt  1977  107 itr 104 (all), according balance 7 units shall be treated as owe dwelling unit  and exemption under sec . 5 (vi) can be claim rather than claiming for 60 lks and the answers comes as 90 lks .

with all the regards and due respect please check the solution as per standards mention by institute , however i applied for re verification of first group under the presumption that you can apply  for max . of 4 papers by submitting rs. 400 demand draft in favor , however we hope you to take care of issues and allow us to follow the paths sets by you .
if any mistake i am sorry  in that regards , its an humble request to please at least check the matter mention above

Replies (6)

do e-sahayata really helps...i dont think they still have not resolved my query....it has been one month...

E-Sahaya is very good. My query was resolved with in a day.

But I doubt whether it will clear our doubts on subject matters

lets hope atleast u come to know

IS IT NOT HE MATTER WHEATHET  E-SAYA. IS HELPFUL OR NOT , THE MATTER IS QUESTION ASK BY ME IS RIGHT OR WRONG ...IF I M WRONG PLZ RECTIFY ME

CAN ANYONE PUT SOME LIGHT  IN THIS REGARD

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Company
19 September 2026
Finance Manager

Mugdha Art Studio

Hyderabad

CA

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 18 September 2026
Industrial Trainee

Twenty Point Nine Five Ventures Private Limited

Noida

CA Inter

View Details
Company
08 September 2026
Semi-Qualified Assitant

Subrahmanyam & Sivudu CA Firm

Hyderabad

CA Inter

View Details
Company
29 September 2026
Work at home

Lottery.sambad.tv

Bhopal

Others

View Details
Company
Featured 21 September 2026
Consultant - Reporting

Finrep Advisors LLP

Mumbai

CA

View Details
Company
22 September 2026
Account Assistant

Chirag P Shah & Co. Chartered Accountant

Pune

B.Com

View Details
Company
20 September 2026
Semi Qualified CA

Navin & Associates

Mumbai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
15 September 2026
Client-site CA associate

Aditya Muley and Co

Mumbai

CA

View Details