CA Final Student M.Com
1241 Points
Joined November 2008
As per my opinion:
a) In your given query X has its own land & he himself is constructing the building, which means that he himself is providing service to himself. For taxable event to arise there must be at least 2 distinct parties. In your query service receiver & service provider are same. Hence no liability for Service Tax
b) Here when X is employing labour contractors means that he is availing the service of contract labourer. In other words he is the receipient of service. Hence again he is not liable to service tax.