Practising CA
33428 Points
Joined April 2009
In my opinion Financial assets includes Equity Shares also.
*
The basis remained in forming such opinion is -
the definition of "financial institution" given in Section 45-I of the RBI Act-1934.
Please go through Section 45 I (c).
*
In my view we have to go in the following manner from upward to downward-
*
First we have to decide , whether it is an NBFI or not. Apply the test of 40-I(c) for its activity too.
*
Then we have to decide the type of NBFI.
*
Being an NBFI first , by idetifying it as a Loan Company at a subsequent stage , character of financial assets and income generated therefrom by an NBFI would not change .
*
So by going through "AS26 way" shares are Financial Assets- and Income from shares is income from Financial Assets.
*
Alternate route- Shares could not be treated as other than financial assets and as it is not correct to say that shares are goods held for sale & purchase.
*
As such in my view , the contention of company may not be correct.