LIVE GST Certification Course by CA Arun Chhajer begins 27th April. Register Now!!

Manish valecha or dinesh madan for isca

Mohit (CA) (755 Points)

25 December 2013

Dear all,

Just wanted to know which is a good book for ISCA - Dinesh Madan or Manish Valecha. I basically wanted a book that has copy pasted from Institute Mat. Could you suggest which is the best book for ISCA(leaving the Institute Mat)?

Reply
Follow
Share

23 Replies

Sourav (Achieving d UnAchieved) (991 Points)
Replied 25 December 2013

In my opinion Go for manish valechha if you can memorize answers. Dinesh Madan is good but consists of too simple words which doesnot fetch marks in exams.

Mohit (CA) (755 Points)
Replied 25 December 2013

Oh ok.. But i am not that kind of a person who can memorise things and remember word to word in the exam. What max i can do is just go through the points and write on my own in the exam... Very difficult to write exactly word to word in the exam. So shall I go ahead with Dinesh Madan only?

Sathish M (Management Accountant) (40581 Points)
Replied 25 December 2013

ICAI study material Full stop.

CA Surbhi Rajpoot (CA, M.com,) (154 Points)
Replied 25 December 2013

hii Mohit..... I think no one can write word to word ans in exam.....but if we can remeber the main points & understd the meaning then we can easily write in detail abt the point.

the plus point of the book is u can easily understd the concepts & if u able to learn some keywords for some imp topics....u can easily learn them

i also refered Manish Valecha book & i find it easy to learn & remember the points. so i think u go for manish valecha book.

3 Like

rahul (Chartered Accountant) (5570 Points)
Replied 25 December 2013

Manish Valechha with practice manual... Best combination to get 60+ Full study mat is given in simplified manner with practical examples.. No need to waste time in study material. Dinesh madan is also good but some chapters 3, 5, 6, 8, 10 given in madan sir book are worst.. Better go for Manish Valechha or Study mat dont take any chance.

Avantika (CA Finals) (216 Points)
Replied 25 December 2013

Originally posted by : Surbhi Rajpoot
	hii Mohit..... I think no one can write word to word ans in exam.....but if we can remeber the main points & understd the meaning then we can easily write in detail abt the point. the plus point of the book is u can easily understd the concepts & if u able to learn some keywords for some imp topics....u can easily learn them i also refered Manish Valecha book & i find it easy to learn & remember the points. so i think u go for manish valecha book.

1 Like

mayank agarwal (CA fianlist BCOM(H) CS student ) (577 Points)
Replied 26 December 2013

throw both of them in dustbin and read PM and study module .

1 Like

CA Vikram Singh (CA, M.B.A,M.COM) (293 Points)
Replied 27 December 2013

Originally posted by : rahul
	Manish Valechha with practice manual... Best combination to get 60+ Full study mat is given in simplified manner with practical examples.. No need to waste time in study material. Dinesh madan is also good but some chapters 3, 5, 6, 8, 10 given in madan sir book are worst.. Better go for Manish Valechha or Study mat dont take any chance.

you can also refer ca vikram kapoor.

these r good and easy to understand ..

Attached File : 278797 1265012 isca vikram kapoor.pdf downloaded: 1426 times

CA.ViVeK M ACA (ACCOUNTS DEPARTMENT) (28544 Points)
Replied 27 December 2013

The subject like ISCA is too technical and system oriented. This is difficult to re collect later due to technicality nature of the subject. Dinesh madan language is simple and easy to learn. So, i will suggest Dinesh madan.