Joining service before completing CA

others 619 views 15 replies

Dear Friends,

Many a students asks me about joining service in corporate sector before completion of CA. The main reason for most of the cases is that they could not passout the final exam within a stipulated time and hence they have to support their family and do not want to be dependent on them.

It is a good though. but as usual there are several drawbacks of it -

1. On IPCC/Inter basis you could not get good package in corporate sector

2. Due to qualification not completed you do not have bargaining power

3. Many companies do not prefer semi-qualified staff because of - (a) knowledge of candidate (b) lack of surity of continuty (c) exam leave (d) uncertainity of period of service

 

I would say, from my experiance, that degree matter more than your hardworking / smart working skills. A qualified person can get more opportunities than a semi-qualified.

If you join the corporate sector before qualification - then -

1. you have to give first priority to service and office, thereby your main goal of becoming a qualified becomes secondary target

2. you may not get desired leave for preparation for exam

3. in many cases on day to basis you may find difficulties to study for regularly for 2 hrs a day due to burden of office work

 

Best Regards,

Ghanshyam

Replies (15)

I am sharing my marks of past exams in CA Final 2nd Group (Old) -

 

Gr II  Nov 2010  May 2010  Nov 2009  June 2009  Nov 2008  May 2008  Nov 2007  May 2007
ROLL Number 6803 7748 8546 7797 6970   5861 20975
        costing exemption lapsed        
Cost Management 66 € 66 32 63 € 63 € NA 63 50
Management Information & Control Systems 21 37 43 39 26 NA 32 15
Direct Taxes 43 46 44 37 39 NA 37 24
Indirect Taxes 51 33 38 55 36 NA 27 36
Total 181 182 157 194 164 0 159 125

All this is happening due to lack of devotion towards study on regular basis.

Thanks sir for sharing this. if any body can join the CA firm to enhance his knowledge about direct taxes & indirect taxes which helps him in his second group study a lot. what is ur openion.

Thannks.

Agree with Ghanshyam ji

It is right.............................agree with the Ghansyamji.....................

And thanx for sharing...........................................................................

Originally posted by : HARISH MEHTA

Thanks sir for sharing this. if any body can join the CA firm to enhance his knowledge about direct taxes & indirect taxes which helps him in his second group study a lot. what is ur openion.

Thannks.

 Dear Harish,

It is again subjective. If the understanding between the student and CA is clear then there should not be a problem.  But no doubt he has to give proper time on regular basis for his studies.

reply to one PM :-

When you join service in corporate sector on the basis Inter / PCC and after some years you get qualified, then after becoming qualified CA your package may be lower than that of a fresh qualified CA. This is because u joined the service at lower package... at that time u r semi qualified... does not have power to negotiate... the base package is lower and on that you get increase at average rate of your company... in the long duration the person who joined service after Qualification will get more package that the person who joined service on the basis of Semi-qualification.

thanks raviji for your comment

Really good and a moral to those who are doing the job before completing their CA course, Good work

 

  Group II

 MAY        2011      
ROLL Number "( Whatever May Be )"
   

 

 

 

 
         
Cost Management 61
     
Management Information & Control Systems 41      
Direct Taxes 58      
Indirect Taxes 57      
Total

217

 

Ghanshyamji ,

May the above marks be yours in May 2011.

With all the best from all of us .

 

  Group II

 MAY        2011      
ROLL Number "( Whatever May Be )"
   

 

 

 

 
         
Cost Management 61
     
Management Information & Control Systems 41      
Direct Taxes 58      
Indirect Taxes 57      
Total

217

 

Ghanshyamji ,

May the above marks be yours in May 2011.

With all the best from all of us .

Dear Paras Ji ,

thanks for your comment. can you share with me how you have arrived at these marks? One small correction from my side, I have exemption in costing with 66 marks and this will be valid upto Nov 11 exam.

Best Regards,

Ghanshyam

After clearing my inter in 1994 I had given final exam as per the old course till 1995 Nov exam. There after I had not appeared for the exam. Again I started from 2004-05. Marks of my 1st Group are as below - for May 05 and Nov 05 exam I am not remembering the marks - sorry for that - but in both the exam the marks were pretty low - 135~150.

 

Gr I  Nov 2006  May 2006
ROLL Number 22411 23197
     
Advanced Accounting 59 57
Management Accounting and Financial Analysis 44 47
Advanced Auditing 48 43
Corporate Laws and Secretarial Practice 49 38
Total 200 185
Originally posted by : Ghanshyam Joshi

Dear Paras Ji ,

thanks for your comment. can you share with me how you have arrived at these marks? One small correction from my side, I have exemption in costing with 66 marks and this will be valid upto Nov 11 exam.
Ghanshyam

I  have arrived  these marks through intution,

but you have improved my hopes by increasing 5 marks. 

So let me allow, to keep the marks with an additional clause of " minimum marks will be obtained by you."

Now, I wish the same for other 3 subjects also.    

 

thanks Sir,


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register