"placements who need it" we people can earn better than that  

they need somebody to guide, to expose there views like college in placements but we can do it our own

if they let them try in there own they r worth less

 

All hypocrites. When they want to, then they say '' CA IS THE BEST PROFESSION ''. When it comes to comparing salaries, they say '' DONT COMPARE, CA IS UNIQUE ''....... 

.

.

The data is conclusive by itself. MBA is a much better course than CA. Of course, if some smart guy wants to say that TAKE ALL MBA STUDENTS ( demonstrating his sub standard statistical sampling approach ), Then I will say that TAKE THE TOP 6000 MBA GUYS EVERY YEAR WHICH ARE COMPARABLE TO THE NUMBER OF FRESH CA'S. And then compare. Even then, CAs are gonna get lower ssalaries and lower placement %

Originally posted by : sahil singla
	ya it's true...CA is totally a different field than MBA....CA's r d kings n queens in terms of Accounting ,taxation n Auditing....with d passage of time CA's will also hav such a commanding position in d field

Agree with u sahil......Salary is not a big deal....Knowledge and intelligence matters!!

what is the use of knowlegde n intelligence iif does not fetch good salry !!but i beg to differ.. good n intelligent CAs will not  find difficulty to earn more..the numbers r certainly very low..conclusion all CAs r not good enough almost IIMS passed out r very good..so differnce in salry is well evident......

If u r very intelligent n taken commerce join b.com n enroll for CA course...simultaneoly u can do CS at about age of 22 u will have B.Com + CA + CS..if u have good practical training in good CA firm go ahead with good comapny like hul/p & g/itc etc. or u like audit/tax even u may join big 4...try to bulid 3-4 years of good work ex...so can always do MBA from IIMs or ISB..certanly then u can at advantage beacuse u have deeper knowledge...u can very good package in campus palcement of iims/isb...logic CA/CS with rank plus good work experience plus top mba degree can help u seeing very  good salary in the tabel.......say mandar pramod dixit too who got rank 1 in ca final have big 4 experince plus industrail tarining from HSBC plus post CA work ex from HUl...now palning to join IIMs.......this is very good way..unless u r like vineet sodhani who have diffrent approach in life he who aready set in practice,writing book n alreadt earning alot........

lemme add a hindi word. this is "pakhandi-pan". Mba >>>>>>>>>> CA Assume; 2500 CA pass out every year. Compare them with 2500 from top MBA colleges of india; u will see a yawning gap. Cream of CA students is no match against cream of MBA students.

hey jose if u compare 2500 students with top  2500 students of top mba collge CAs stand no where.....IIMs have 2000 seats add 2-3 institiutes say sp jain,jamnabajaj salary average always above 10 lakhs....even welinger not in top 20 institues ahead of CAs average salry .....strange but true...get ur facts right.....

@ Shinoj. Jose and you are saying the same thing. 

 

Now a days Professionals from every field join M.B.A. Few years back A Person from Civil service had cracked CAT at the age of 42.

Do other professionals compare their returns M.B.A's.

Every Engineer prepare for CAT during his 4 years course, Doctors after 5.5 years of M.B.B.S take a break of one year, then prepare for M.D, and few goes to M.B.A .

Due to extreame hardship in C.A People compare return with M.B.A, But one should think going at IIM is even difficult than C.A, It is constant preparation of at least 02 years pluse personality Factor. People prepare for it at their 03rd or 04 the Year of Engineering Course.

IIT + IIM is most preferable Tag in coorporate. Now somebody read chetan bhagat's Book Five point some one based on which three idiot has been made, How IIT People has to study hard day and night or meet some IIM Person they too have to work very hard.

M.B.A is an Post Degree Course, where Student already have a professional skill. In foreign countries practical experience is a  norm to gain entry in this course.

I  think C.A is a professional skill at par with M.B.B.S OR B.TECH as per coorporate ratings and post professional skill is  M.B.A where entire course approach is different, then this comparison is unwanted.

C.A is more focussed towards Law, accountancy, Tax and M.B.A is a complete Package for Managers. It is totally industry need oriented course, If one is talented he should go for M.B.A after getting degree qualification, No body has stopped any body to acquire further skill

Please stop demeaning your course, Every body know pitfalls of C.A before joining that.

Do you know what is Current course  fee of I.S.B, Jamna Lal or welingner

GRASS of  OTHER SIDE ALWAYS LOOK GREENER

 

 

 

 

Originally posted by : Amit Nishania
	Some data is missing dude, no. of student appearing in the placement and the procedure of getting into IIM-C, as anyone can take CA but have to go very hard for IIM-C, dats y so much difference. If u want to compare then take all the MBA institute, u will find they are being hired @ Rs 10000 pm, even an Inter Pass student earn more than that, and amount spend for getting that MBA degree is also to high. A quote by Ratan Tata- " I need MBA for running my business, But CA to teach them how to run the business" Just find the salary package offered by ITC to all MBA from IIM, engineer from IIT and Fresher CA- it's 10.61 lac per annum at present and next year it might rise to 12.5 lacs. That's all, now u can compare and get u result or decision.

 AGREE WITH AMIT

forget iim; let's keep them aside for a moment. Take 2500 students from FMS,IIT-MBA programmes, Symbiosis, SP jain, Narsee monjee; XLRI, jamnalal bajaj, ISB hyderabad; even they will be much sought after and better than the 2500 CAs passing out every year. ICAI only says lies to mollify its students who can't get good jobs due to the carelessness and negligence of icai officers(look my previous posts of fiasco of icai ahmedabad branch placement- they forgot to invite reliance). lmao

i thnk u have compared d placement situation only. wat about practice? undoubtedly iiim-c students have great potential though can't compare few hundreds of iim-c wid thousands of caz

I AM ALSO AGREE SUNOJ

C.A.s are the source of  knowledge for a company whereas M.B.A.s are the presenter of that knowledge . So, to take efficient decisions one has to think intelligently & thinking intelligently is not enough you should also know the direction where you have to apply that thinking, hence both the profession have their own importance.

C.A.+M.B.A. can take you a long road ahead in your life.............................................................................................

Ab bolo, CPT wale se bhi sunta padta hai. Its like if u are arguing with your girlfriend and you have a valid point; once she starts crying; u lose the dual. Same thing with CA>>> IIM supporter; the last thing they saw is "CA has knowledge.......and blah blah". Then what do you think, iim wale are anguthaa chaap.