MSME Certified Income Tax Live Batch to commence from 21st January 2022. Limited Seats. Register Now!!

taskopad

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Icwai demands drop chartered from icai

Page no : 2

(Guest)

Dear Rajkumar Sir i agree with your comments but at first icai oppose the name change of icwai


(Guest)

ICAI and ICWAI  both are the professional institutions which have separate function and separate objective, why they interfiering each other in their pesonal business


(Guest)

Dear Santosh,

Please know the fact, ICWA did not talk to ICAI for the sake of Name change. Govt asked three bodies for LLP. But ICWAI hided the name change proposal. It was MCA informed that ICAI is intereted in the case of name chnange.

Even Supreme court favored ICAI in the case of IFCAI for accounting regulation. How ICWAI  went it self for name change without taking ICAI in its consent.

1 Like

anirban dey (MEMBER) (37 Points)
Replied 16 December 2011

ALL R POLITICS RATHER THAN TAKING RIGHT STEPS

1 Like

CA.AMAR MOHAPATRA (MANAGER-INDIRECT TAX) (665 Points)
Replied 16 December 2011

Originally posted by : Richank Garg

Whatever the reason may be but the word "Chartered" is the life of Chartered Accountant profession. There is no doubt about that and should remain attached with ICAI.


1000% agree with  Mr Richank

anirban dey (MEMBER) (37 Points)
Replied 16 December 2011

IF CA AND CWA BOTH WILL CREATE MOU ABOUT MEMBERSHIP,EXEMPTION THEN ALL PROBLEM MAY BE STOPPED.ITS JUST AN EXPECTATION.

CA.AMAR MOHAPATRA (MANAGER-INDIRECT TAX) (665 Points)
Replied 16 December 2011

Originally posted by : SANTOSH KUMAR DALAI

SO SIR WHAT IS THE PROBLEM WITH ICAI TO CHANGE THE NAME OF ICWAI TO ICMAI, Why they object to icwai, both have setup under an act of parliament.


i am agree with that ..both have setup under an act of parliament.....but sir g there is difference between a chartered accountant and a cost accountant. ......everybody knows!!!!!cost accountant are not the management accountant...they are only cost accountant.

 


(Guest)

This is not feasible , as both course has diffrent in it nature and structure.

CA is taken as full time studies by most of students ( Please ignore those who have completed artileshattempting CA examps

CWA is taken as part time studies by maximum no. of students .( Mostly by working class)

 

 

Training structure is different , ICAI needs exclusive training in CA firm ( Ignore Dummy articleship)

ICWAI accept training from any where .

2 Like

anirban dey (MEMBER) (37 Points)
Replied 16 December 2011

AT LEAST BOTH BODY CAN ALLOW PAPERS EXEMPTION OR ANY KIND OF MOU WHICH ENRICH OUR COUNTRY BUT FACT IS THAT ALL SEE OWN INTEREST AND IGNORE STUDENTS,MEMBERS INTEREST.

anirban dey (MEMBER) (37 Points)
Replied 16 December 2011

WE ALL NEED TO STOP THIS TOPIC EVERYWHERE THEN ALL WILL BE FINE.BOTH BODY NEED TO SEE PROFESSIONAL ENRICHMENT NOT POLITICS.

RG - A Helping Hand (Company Secretary) (13867 Points)
Replied 16 December 2011

Originally posted by : anirban dey

WE ALL NEED TO STOP THIS TOPIC EVERYWHERE THEN ALL WILL BE FINE.BOTH BODY NEED TO SEE PROFESSIONAL ENRICHMENT NOT POLITICS.


TOTALLY AGREE WITH YOU ANIRBAN...AS BOTH THE INSTITUTE ARE IMPORTANT FOR THE GROWTH OF COUNTRY AND PROFESSION.

 

RG

anirban dey (MEMBER) (37 Points)
Replied 16 December 2011

Both body need see own matter,it will be best solution.

DK (SERVICE) (116 Points)
Replied 16 December 2011

CA s are grooming because they are growing under monopilitic society where Statutory Audit can be done by CA only.Let other institute member be allowed to practice in the same field in view of the liberalized policy after 1991.Members may please go through the debate in Rajyasabha that what is real realisation will be in the mind of some MP , But it was preconceived mind of Veerappa Molily based on the strong lobby of CA s, the Minsiter has moved the bills.As competition act is coming very sortly, so ICWA should appeal in the court for  giving equal opportunity in the field of Statutory Audit like CA.Because in India Minister only listen when our court orders them.It is funny that in 2004 Standing Committee has recommended the change THE NAME from ICWAI to ICMAI.But it is sad that ICWAI when headed by person having dual qualification make compromise.Although ICWAI has very strong case, when it will appraoch the court.Seeing the mood of President and Vice President.I think that justice will be given by the act of court only.

3 Like

anirban dey (MEMBER) (37 Points)
Replied 16 December 2011

Both body also headed by only single degree holder then he/she will see own body's interest.all this must need to think by members b4 voting.

Sanket ( ACA, ACMA, CS) (Self-Employed) (72 Points)
Replied 16 December 2011

Originally posted by : Raj Kumar Gupta


This is not feasible , as both course has diffrent in it nature and structure.

CA is taken as full time studies by most of students ( Please ignore those who have completed artileshattempting CA examps

CWA is taken as part time studies by maximum no. of students .( Mostly by working class) 

Training structure is different , ICAI needs exclusive training in CA firm ( Ignore Dummy articleship)

ICWAI accept training from any where .

 

   

 

Where does a CA firm provides exclusive training in management.

A management training can be done anywhere and not limited to Corporates.

One must have heard of management student learning from mumbai Tiffin Dabba wallas.

 

 

   


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  





Subscribe to the latest topics :

Search Forum:


expand_less