From 31 to 63 in isca!!!

Final 2607 views 32 replies

This was my second attempt. My first attempt got ruined solely due to ISCA - despite getting 426 total I failed. I was devastated. I criticised the ICAI as much as I can. I was a rank holder in IPCC and now a failure in finals had completely shattered me.

But then days passed. I had applied for certified copy. When I got it I noticed the following things which I would like to share:

MODULE LANGUAGE IS THE GITA- Even if you write what is logically right but not in words of ICAI module then you will have to pay penalty for it. The quantum of penalty is inversely proportional to the level of intellect of the examiner. I got straight 0 in questions where words of module were not found - SAD but true.

ATTEMPTING 100 DOES NOT GUARANTEE 40: This time I attempted 92 and got 63 - just by writing module words.

THIS SUBJECT DOES CHECK THE MEMORY FUNCTION OF YOUR BRAIN AND NOT ANY LOGICAL FUNCTION - Suggested answers sometimes do not even mention the name of the company which is given in case study!!!!! - SAD BUT TRUE!!!!

DO NOT FLAUNT KNOWLEDGE: For those people who say articleship helps in writing CA final. I completely disagree for this subject. I wrote a practical example of a transaction processing system which I saw at my client AND I GOT A ZERO IN THAT.

RULE IS SIMPLE: The closer your language is to module, the more you get. Whether you CRAM IT OR UNDERSTAND THEN CRAM IT thats upto you.

Thanks..

 

Replies (32)

I got 202 in Group 2 But Flunked due to costing, ya you heard it right due to costing, could you please share some tips to get leverage in costing, i got an exemption in DT, in costing i couldn't score even a 40,

Urgent Crisis !! Please Help..

Ashutosh

Hi Ashutosh!!

For costing I would suggest make a bank of questions which contain all the varieties and solve them at least 3 times INDEPENDENTLY.

Search for newer questions like from RTPs , mock tests and solve them in examination conditions.

Always keep a track of your own solutions. DO NOT USE ROUGH WORK.

What I used to do was to mark my mistakes with a red pen and conceptual errors with a green pen, along with a note on that error. THIS REALLY HELPS at the time of final revision.

PLS DONOT IGNORE THEORY BY KEEPING IT FOR THE LAST DAY OR LAST WEEK. IT REALLY HELPS AS COSTING PAPER IS LENGTHY. ARRANGE SOME GOOD NOTES for it.

ALso practice OR in the same manner. It can really help you to cross 55 with ease

@ Vikas - God Guide and Bless you.You have Passed your Finals.You are amongst the very few people who speak the truth after Crossing the Bridge.

This is the Harsh truth of ISCA.

Thanks for this Post.

institute material is best book for success.Students fail in exam due to ignorance of it and then they blame icai. congo vikas verma

Hi Vikas verma,

Urgently Required!!!!!!!

Please share strategy to get exemption in ISCA.

I have tried, but unfortunately Failed.

 

 Hi Shomin

pls focus on ICAI module.. there is no shortcut
and please do not stop revising it. Otherwise it will vapourise.

 

Revise by speaking aloud - to yourself. that is the best technique.

I daily used to revise this subject. and if u have less time u can easily skip one chapter ( BUT ONLY WHEN U R STUDYING MODULE OR MODULE NOTES) I skipped chapter one - didnt even touch it. Believe me just attempt 90 marks in pure module language and get an exemption

Very true.... The only strategy to crack exemption in this paper is to study the institute's Study Module. Even I referred the module alongwith practice manual and RTP and secured 61 marks. In my case I cleared 2nd group because of this exemption as my Costing was very weak and secured on 43 marks in it.

Hi ,

I heartly appreciate ur suggestion.

I have one more query for nov 2014 in paper IDT , case law were from which book?

I had studied IDT case law from ICAI book , but i didnot find it exam case law from this book except for one case.

Please reply!!!!!!

See if you closely study what ICAI says in its RTP is that not always you have to write the case law name. If you have conceptually sound knowledge, you can answer with reason . There was one question in DT I remember in May 2014 in which i wrote the concept and conclusion and got 3 out of 4 ( as per my certified copy).

 

Anyways the case laws were like bolt from the blue this time. They were from Bangar's book.

One more question to you Mr. Vikas, from were to practise the sums of IDT (Mostly ask Valuation) which is there for nearly 25 marks ?

Please reply brother!!!!!

Thnx to all u r discussion helps me a lot

for valuation questions I searched for questions rule wise, make a bank of questions rule wise by searching in PM, RTP, your class notes or reference book.

You may also search on CCI for questions.

rule wise preparation helps in ensuring comprehensive coverage

 

Thankyou.

I APPRECIATE your view.

My marks in group 2

AMA : 47 marks out of 60 attempted. Book followed :ICAI Practice Manual.

ISCA : 27. Book follwed :2 times Manish Vallecha,2 times Vishal Saraogi,2 times Institute Study Material, 1 time ICAI Practice Manual, 1 time RTP. I made special efforts for this paper but all in vain.

DT : 48. Book follwed : Bangar Quick Referencer cum Compiler.

IDT : 61.Book follwed : Bangar Quick Referencer cum Compiler. All the relevant and irrelevant case laws which came in the exam were from this book only.

 ISCA is such a pain in the @ $$ :(


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register