Dummy Articleship - De-recognition of full training period -

https://www.icai.org/post.html?post_id=5854&c_id=219

Dear Sree how did it come to ur knowledge that these articles were  dummy?

i dodt know Institute has its own means

There are hundreds and thousands of dummy article students why only 3 are caught????

i think somebody gave complaint on them

institute keeps confidentially the details of complaint  given persons

this is good day for the persons who are doing Genuine articles

bad day for the persons who did dummy articles and who are doing dummy articles

ye baat to sahi hai but aticleship transfer and dummy articleship k bich mein kya relation hai ???

Why they don't allow articleship transfer stiil yet ????

lol i have 38 frnds who are in dummy articleship :P

then i think the membership of those CA's shd also be de-rerecognised///..they r also equally punishable

Posted On 11 May 2010 at 10:52

then i think the membership of those CA's shd also be de-rerecognised///..they r also equally punishable

 

---

 

absolutely right!!! all such CAs should be disqualified for life time!!

articleship itself should be banned for ever from CA Course.. who said dummies cant clear CA Finals and cant survive thereafter... ?? ITS NOT ROCKET SCIENCE TO CLEAR CA!!! ANY BODY CAN DO SO IF STUDIED WELL... AND NOT QUIT IF NOT CLEAR... TRY LIKE A SPIDER BUILDING ITS HOUSE... DONT QUIT.

its all fake...that 3 have been derecognised...khud ki  site hai isliye kuch bhi likh degi aur hum dar jayenge???? huh

i also feel the same. But if they have realy been punished; their CAs also should be banned for life from practise. Why only students? But icai wont do so; because they are their vote banks and they compose of their power? I will give a very similar situation. A terrorist named Salman was arrested in UP; and he was a runaway convict from batla house encounter. Police got enough proof from salman that he had gone to meet a powerful SP politician. Even then; that neta wasn't even arrested. Same with icai. Jaise police majority dummy ko chhu bhi nahi sakte; waise hi majority of terrorists are roaming free. Police can only do dadagiri with arrested terrorists

Students doing dummy articleship might have thought that the training is or will be uneffective!.

But it is effective when it is done by the perscripttion of the ICAI. But the student getting training in most cases do not get full training or doing only a routine job which is known to all. Eg.: entering / feeding the data in the PC  as this work is known even to a data entry operator!

Students are frustuated by giving simple work, tuff work which need their guidence / teaching (which will not be received by him).

some one said ,, 

then i think the membership of those CA's shd also be de-rerecognised///..they r also equally punishable,,

what did our ICAI do so far in case of SATYAM Fiasco,fraudsters?.for some time they say courts,enquiry,investigation,bla..bla...people wil forget.then same story.our ICAI president(old during satyam fiasco),he cleary said law is restricting us to take action on such CA'S.their membership is safe,as a board member their place is safe.ultimately the losers are students,employees,public.who is in turn losing hopes with useless rules,regulations.

i think ICAI shud modify articleship rules.

The attitude of ICAI seems to be worse in this regard; It is the Chartered Accountant who has permitted them to be dummy articles. If it so, why should they penalise the students unless action is taken against the member? Just as in our constitution, giving incite to do crime is equivalent to the crime itself, the same has been done here. The institute must clarify/expose further details in this regard.