Practicing Chartered Accountant
573 Points
Joined June 2021
Agreed on the point that the gain of said nature are mentioned in the list u/s 10.
But if something has to be taxed under the head capital gain then there has to be a
" transfer of capital asset". Unless these criterions are satisfied one cannot tax such income under the head of capital gain.
In the given case, rural agricultural land itself is not considered as a "capital asset" which is one of the criteria. Though there is a transfer, it is not a transfer of capital asset. For understanding purpose one can say it is transfer of other than capital asset. Hence the charging section is not invoked. So it is not taxable under the head capital gains