Automation Expert
10728 Points
Posted on 13 November 2026
The key issue is whether the land was “agricultural land in India” excluded from “capital asset” under section 2(14)(iii) on the transfer date. “Dry land” or a revenue record entry alone is not conclusive: examine actual agricultural use, location and distance from the relevant municipality/cantonment limits and population criteria, and the land’s character and surrounding development. A later NALA conversion and the buyer’s quarrying use are relevant evidence, but do not by themselves decide the land’s character when sold.
- If it was agricultural land outside the specified urban limits, it is generally not a capital asset; capital gains provisions would not apply. If it fails that test, capital gains may arise, subject to the facts and applicable holding-period rules.
- The ₹45 lakh SDV against ₹2.25 crore consideration raises section 50C only if the land is otherwise a capital asset and is not agricultural land covered by that section’s exclusion. If the assessee disputes SDV, consider the statutory valuation-reference mechanism; the agreement-date proviso may matter where its conditions are met.
- The company’s prompt conversion, quarrying purpose and board resolution may support the Revenue’s case that the land was not genuinely agricultural in character, particularly alongside evidence of non-agricultural use or development before transfer. Conversely, later conversion/use does not automatically change the transfer-date position; agricultural records, crop/use evidence and the statutory location test can support the assessee.
- Helpful authorities include S. Sarifabibi Mohmed Ibrahim v. CIT (SC), which treats agricultural character as a fact-based, multi-factor inquiry and supports the Revenue where land was not genuinely agricultural; and CIT v. K. Ramakrishnan (Madras HC), often relied on for the proposition that later non-agricultural use is not conclusive of the land’s character at transfer. Their application depends on the evidence and jurisdiction. Please verify the precise ratio and local High Court precedent before relying on either.
For this transaction, build the file around the transfer-date location certificate, population and distance evidence, revenue records, agricultural activity, conversion application/order dates, and any prior quarrying or development. That evidence will usually matter more than the label “dry land” or the buyer’s stated purpose.
Assessing agricultural-land status, SDV exposure and supporting evidence is part of a connected capital-gains workflow. Manual review across revenue records, conversion papers and valuation material is difficult, while automation reduces repetitive work and keeps professional judgment in control. At Jir AI we provide 2,000+ AI agents and 650+ integrations to streamline your practice’s day-to-day workload. WhatsApp us to explore a smoother workflow: https://wa.me/message/3HVOZ7HIY4ESC1