MSME Certified Income Tax Live Batch to commence from 21st January 2022. Limited Seats. Register Now!!

taskopad

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

CA vs ICWA

Page no : 3

Gayathri (Cost Accountant) (203 Points)
Replied 10 March 2011

who said clearing CWA is damn easy Mr.Phani kumar?

CA Vasiullah (Vasi) (Audit Executive) (1813 Points)
Replied 10 March 2011

What about CS guys?

Where it stands compare to CA and ICWA?

Gayathri (Cost Accountant) (203 Points)
Replied 10 March 2011

Every profession has its own privilege.

Kamal Kothari (CWA) (169 Points)
Replied 10 March 2011



Ravi Sisodia Sir has explained about both profession in a very simple manner outlining importance of both CA and CWA. Thanks.

CA phanikumar chebolu (B.com CMA (CS professional))   (556 Points)
Replied 10 March 2011

hello m/s.Gayathri, Puja, madhura, subramanya  and so many.....



I heard and personally came across wid "n" number of frnds..... everybody said that CWA is damn easy..

just wait for a while.. even i will also prove that passing CWA is damn easy.. i m pursuing CA and CS...

only just to prove that ICWA is damn easy i registerd for CWA inter. I m poor average student. In june'11 my cwa inter attempt is there. . and CA final in may'11.  I will study for CWA inter  only for 10 to 15days... may b less than that... consequently i will pass CWA Inter. not only pass i  will get gud rank also.. Same like in CWA final also.. dont say this is over confidence... save this msg and save this page also.. just confirm with me hw much i rank i got aftr declaring  results.... once again saying, passing CWA is as child's play.. child's play.. child's play... even hw many u argue or dont accept it, i will prove it.. just wait and seeee......





CA Rajat Jain (CA) (1672 Points)
Replied 10 March 2011

ca is better

sumit bhatia (ca-final article) (368 Points)
Replied 10 March 2011

Every Profession has their own PROS & CONS that doesn't means that one is better than other....Its upon your own calibre that how you gonna excel in your life and for that even a single profeesional degree is enough .

Guys tell me for

1. CA is it compulsory to do training IN either CWA or CS.

2. Is there is any exemption in  the Either Of CWA Or CS after doing the CA

cma ravi tanwar (ca final) (106 Points)
Replied 10 March 2011

Dear all

I am sorry to say that all you people are not understanding the psyche of PHANI KUMAR and I must confess that I also agree with him to some extent.

The problem here is that CA students have this inherent superiority complex that makes them believe that ca is the numero uno course and all other courses are petty and less rewarding.They are so much emotionally attached with this course that can’t tolerate a word against this course.THIS INCLUDES ME ALSO.

Because I don’t like beating around the bush ,I will categorically explain my opinion through an example:

Suppose there are  2 class 12 th commerce passouts (both are mediocres). The first one enrolls for CA and the second one goes for ICWA.The latter completes his CWA at the age of 22 and gets placed in a maharatna psu at a salary of 7 lacs per annum.He also enjoys his student days and college life too.

The CA guy is still struggling and till 25 he is still unqualified and earning a paltry sum of maximum 15 k a month.Besides this, he has to bear the wrath of his parents,relatives and his ca boss always keeps him on tenterhooks.Atlast ,when he qualifies he gets a shock of his life when he gets shortlisted only by genpact with a pay packet of 4 lacs.

We all know the level of knowledge and expertise CA students have,still these students don’t get a fair deal and are at the receiving end.

We have to think from point of view of getting settled in life rather than attaching a prestige issue with CA.

Mind you I have seen many of seniors and friends who have left ca and are living a life of mediocrity and there are also a few of them who have slipped into severe depression.

So guys choice is yours.

ALSO GUYS I AM NOT PRO ICWA.I AM TOTALLY NEUTRAL IN MY OPINION

Comments and criticism welcome

 

cma ravi tanwar (ca final) (106 Points)
Replied 10 March 2011

@ phani kumar

you are saying cwa is damn easy because you are in ca final

ask any student who is doing cwa only,he will give u smashing reply.

i am 200%sure that u will clear it with ur left hand.

This is an undisputed fact that a ca student can clear cwa and cs like a cake walk

VIVEK KEDIA (Salaried) (77 Points)
Replied 10 March 2011

Ravi  is absoultely right.

Phani Kumar  behaving like a kid . He is saying in 15 days  study he will clear CWA inter .

Actually he is not counting the entire year when he was studying for ca whose topics were same as of cwa . So if a guy who is only doinf cwa has to study atleast 8 months.

Phani you are just wasting time on such things. Pls stop and do your job.

CA. Raminder Dhiman (Educational Consultancy)   (189 Points)
Replied 10 March 2011

Salary is not the cireteria for comparision.  Its a pure luck.

CMA Niranjan Avasthi (Manager) (94 Points)
Replied 10 March 2011

Hi Friends,

 Went through all posts and I felt to narrate my views too...

I am a M.com Pas out student and did my Post graduate in marketing and MBA finance distance learning. My age is 25 and I am working with ICICI Mutual fund as Asst. Manager in Sales my sal is 7.5 lks now. I have total exp of 5 years as I did my m.com MBA and Post gard in marketing  bydistance learning. Last June I got registered for CWA Inter and I cleared my CWA Inter Group1 and now in June I am going to apper for Group 2. I agree with Phani that CWA is easier than CA and is flexible too in terms of articleship.I choose CWA because of the same reason> But comparing CA and CWA is allmost like comparing Apples with Oranges. Both course are different and have their own specialisation. One should have vision of their goals and then decide what he or she should persue. there are lot many deciding factors when you get a job. Mere Passing CA or CWA and on that basis comparing salaries is not the right approach to judje the 2 proffessional courses.

     When you have skill and vision of your goal even a B.com graduate can achieve heights. But professional courses along with skills and vision will shorten your journey to those heights.

Happy studying....

1 Like

CA Ravi Sisodia (CA,CS,CMA) (32221 Points)
Replied 10 March 2011

Originally posted by : phanikumar
hello m/s.Gayathri, Puja, madhura, subramanya  and so many.....


I heard and personally came across wid "n" number of frnds..... everybody said that CWA is damn easy..
just wait for a while.. even i will also prove that passing CWA is damn easy.. i m pursuing CA and CS...
only just to prove that ICWA is damn easy i registerd for CWA inter. I m poor average student. In june'11 my cwa inter attempt is there. . and CA final in may'11.  I will study for CWA inter  only for 10 to 15days... may b less than that... consequently i will pass CWA Inter. not only pass i  will get gud rank also.. Same like in CWA final also.. dont say this is over confidence... save this msg and save this page also.. just confirm with me hw much i rank i got aftr declaring  results.... once again saying, passing CWA is as child's play.. child's play.. child's play... even hw many u argue or dont accept it, i will prove it.. just wait and seeee......

 

 what do you want to prove in this social website.

why you show your telent here ?

if you have telent -  think posative not negative. 

dont under estimate any course. every course have value and importance.

3 Like

CA Ravi Sisodia (CA,CS,CMA) (32221 Points)
Replied 10 March 2011

Originally posted by : VIVEK KEDIA

There are 5 lacs ca students  and 50 thousand cwa . It is obvious competition is more in CA.

The ICWAI institute is doing the Job of branding there students from last two years . So they are getting good jobs .  It all matters  "Time"  and nothing else.

 in india more then 70 lakhs MBA students in various universities. according to you their is more compitation amoung them ??

totally irrelevant logic !!!

1 Like

(Guest)

Thank you ravi Sir... i welcome ur concern as a CA... 

And about Phani's post.... hear are my views...

My dear Phani and for all those who are studying for money....

I was infact wondering ... It is pathetic that people are studying for Money...(not all ... atleast not myself..) 

Please don't compare knowledge to money... money is required to live but don't make money as life...

wat is the darn use of becoming a CA without proving to the world that u are a true professional...

Still our Indian CA course is second in the world.. CWA and CS i don't know which rank it stands...

Why don't we the young generation try and strive to make our accounting proffession the best in the world... 

No one is going to remember a CA who earns some 50 to 75 lakhs per annum...

But people remember the CA who has shown some professionalism in the work...

The good example is Mr. T.N.Manoharan Sir.. He was awarded Padma Sri ... not for earning some 50 to 75 lakhs but for his service as a CA to the nation and the ICAI...

I dont have to speacially say about the boon he has given to us " SWP-Direct tax laws " for students....

So.. as a good friend i request you not study to prove something but please study to learn something...

Moreover education is not a child's play... it is the key of becoming a MAN from a CHILD... hope u will turn into a MAN...

 

My apologies if i am rude in conveying the message i meant... but i really mean it....

3 Like

Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  





Subscribe to the latest topics :

Search Forum:




expand_less