Ca is not a good course

5498 views 80 replies

I have seen many people who are simply graduate having 4-5 years exp and MBA having 2-3 year exp.earn more than a CA and get job easily than a CA and a CA inter.

And CA candidates after qualifying when goes for interview lots of questions do you have practical exposure in Assessment, Appeal, transfer pricing, investment banking, finance.....they dont understand every candidate is not trained in Big 4....and a CA if working in a particular industry then he faces the questions you dont have practical exposure in our industry so sorry......

what rubbish is this......to get practical exposure in each and every thing is not possible....there are many few things coming...xbrl,revised schedule, companies act 2013 a CA is capable of applying anything by learning then why there is big issue in giving jobs to CAs...

aur CA ka ye haal he to CA final to kya kahe.............what is the use of investing so many years and ruining our life in such a course...........

Replies (80)

Parul salary of a person depends upon his skill and knowledge.Knowledge necessarily does not come from doing any course.And ofcourse CA is a good course.

 

In which course do you expect  that in a petty sum you can get world class study mat and knowledge. MBA fees are normally high and without loan many cant afford MBA.

 

Even if you fail in CA but you have done rigrous training you can find  a decent job.

 

Please do not blame CA course if anyone is  not able to match expectations of the institute. 

Parul salary of a person depends upon his skill and knowledge.Knowledge necessarily does not come from doing any course.And ofcourse CA is a good course.

 

In which course do you expect  that in a petty sum you can get world class study mat and knowledge. MBA fees are normally high and without loan many cant afford MBA.

 

Even if you fail in CA but you have done rigrous training you can find  a decent job.

 

Please do not blame CA course if anyone is  not able to match expectations of the institute. 

parul ji.. why u getting too much dishearted... i know ur probs are big.. we cant sort it out by words here... but do u think posting these things will help you...!!!

ek CA articleship me kya kya sikhega kaun investment banking ya budgeting wagarah karta he???aur bahut sare CA to apne articles to apne personal kam ke liye use karte he........this is ICAI?????and i am talking about normal MBA from aprivate institute and not of CAT........ICAI kya sikha raha he result kam nikalne ke liye students fail karte he........aur deserving candidates 3-4 attempts ke baad nikalte he to unhe job nahi milti.itna horrible future agar koi course deta he to CA karna hi nahi chahiye.
 

One more thing i want to add here...

 

Though we are not getting high salary or expected salary.. yes i agree with u our life is tough and all... but i hadnt seen any chartered having 7-8 years expereience and doesnt getting his or her expected salary... 

 

Yes we do have struggles even after clearing CA Finals and having jobs in starting years... but in future everything wil get paid off... i had seen that....

 

I m also suffering from these problems, but i know writing here doesnt gonna make any difference .. so working hard towards my expected salary is the only choice i had left with now.... i had trust of myself that one day i wil get what i deserve....

A MBA cant get the respect we had in socities, no other field can give u the respect, value then this... i do beleive this... and this is my personal thinking...

Though money matters a lot specially in middle class family students like us.... but money cant b everything na....

 

Mr. Ankit i am talking about ICAI.....why they dont take any efforts .....if SAP is so esential then make arrangements so that every student can learn and many more new things are coming arrang practical training batches...ICAI has sufficient money to do this th.........make efforts in providing jobs to CAs.....instruct CAs to providee better training to the articles and dont use like theri own servants.........

give them time na.... they are trying... yes i do agree many improvements required...

 

like artlicleship complain desk should b there so that articles can complain

a better job providing desk should be there

professional develpment trainings should b there

practical exposure requirements of markets should be given to students like ERP/SAP

They will do nothing they will make efforts towards collecting money, getting name and fame........aur apni tarifon ke pul bandhane he CA journal me bas.....

laughcheeky

My dear Parul, please understand that no matter in what profession you're in, it's entirely upto you as to how you utilize that professional qualification. Whether it's CA or MBA or any other profession, it doesn't really matter. If you're really serious about it, you can reach whatever position you want to. There'll be "pros and cons" in every profession. So please stop bashing on CA and please stop comparing two different professions!

@ Ankit - What is the average salary running for a CA in industry with 2 to 3 years Expereince?..i know it depends but am asking for average kind of students falling in the ambit of 2 to 4 attempts pass out?

Mr.shrikant mene ek question pucha he usi way me reply kijiye..........how can an article or a fresher CA can have expericne in each and every thing????????why such things are demanded from CA????????

I agree wid you parulji. Even after ICWA, there is no better job available. Wherever I go, they found my degree is very high. There is no scope for ICWA except costing which has no importance in Indian industry.


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register