CA Final Students may get to see answersheet after May

Final 2281 views 14 replies

Hi friends,

 

Here is a welcome news for all of us from ICAI. Institute may allow students to see the answer sheets of CA Final after may 2011.

Here is the text of the article published in Hindu in this regard :

 

Final year CA students may get to see answer sheets

CHENNAI: Final year Chartered Accountancy students should be able to see copy of their answer sheets after May 2011, subject to approval by Central Council members, said Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) president Amarjit Chopra on Monday.

Delivering the special address at ‘Convocation 2010', he said the performance of students was dismal, despite all the coaching classes, and this had to improve. They need to go back to text books and reference books and apply the concepts to the given problems. The Common Proficiency Test needs to be strengthened by bringing in appropriate changes.

To allay the apprehension that ICAI was failing students, it was proposed to allow them to see their answer sheets. The comments of the head examiner on every question would be hosted on the web. Besides, it was decided to host suggested answers for the November exam, one month before the declaration of the result, he said.

According to Mr. Chopra, the ICAI has signed Mutual Recognition Agreements with many nations; it will be signing one with Ireland next month, negotiations were on with New Zealand and Singapore and new initiatives were planned in the African region.

He also said that for the next two years, there would not be any change in the curriculum or in fee structure. It was also proposed to start a virtual classroom by December, which would be cheaper than attending the coaching classes. Distributing the convocation credentials to top nine rank holders from Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh, G. Thiruvasagam, Vice-Chancellor, University of Madras, said, “the higher education system faced an alarming situation due to a mismatch in demand and supply. Though the University gives results of 75 per cent, the employability ratio is only nine per cent, while ICAI gives results of four per cent and the employability is 100 per cent. This is due to good syllabus, effective delivery system, effective examination system, research programmes and global education.”

He asked the students to update their knowledge on a regular basis, act as the conscience of corporate companies and remind them of their corporate social responsibility and be the guardian angels of shareholders.

V. Murali, vice-chairman, Board of Studies said that Chartered Accountants should have focus, work with responsibility, play their role to perfection and render value addition to society.

G. Ramaswamy, vice-president, ICAI, said that a few more international chapters would be opened soon.

 My Views

Wt do u say will it ensure more transparency in the ICAI system of evalaution of answer papers ?? offlate due to low passing % it is said that the results are manipulated. so this welcome move may answer all the students query regarding this. Moreover students at the final level can get to know wt the institute is expecting from them. This indeed was very long awaited i'm glad it might get enforced soon.

This plan should also be implemented for CPT, PCC/IPCC students if not atleast for PCC/IPCC coz once u clear CPT the stakes are very high. CPT passed students have no option but to pursue CA because of the time and efforts invested after clearing CPT in their articleship and exam preparations. So atleast for PCC/IPCC students this system should come into force might help them a lot in building them as a professional as they will get to know early what the institute expects from them.

 

What are ur comments and feedback on this ??

Best Wishes

Prasad R

Source  https://www.hindu.com/2010/08/24/stories/2010082456330500.htm

 

Replies (14)

" Final year Chartered Accountancy students should be able to see copy of their answer sheets after May 2011, subject to approval by Central Council members, said Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) president Amarjit Chopra on Monday" .

 So I think still there are restriction which wont ensure better transperancy...

Subject to approval of council member will mean that for the new system to get implemented the council members will have to approve on this. Once it is approved by them definitely will lead to better transparency.


Jus hoping the council members approve on this new initatiave by ICAI.

 

Originally posted by : Devi Kala


" Final year Chartered Accountancy students should be able to see copy of their answer sheets after May 2011, subject to approval by Central Council members, said Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) president Amarjit Chopra on Monday" .

 So I think still there are restriction which wont ensure better transperancy...

Wow  This is a good opportunity and we can come to know how much we deserve for our presentation and answering skill.Good step by ICAI

Yup a good initiative by ICAI provided it gets implemented.

 

Originally posted by : R.G.Ayyswariya


Wow  This is a good opportunity and we can come to know how much we deserve for our presentation and answering skill.Good step by ICAI

Bolne aur hone main bahut antar hai

Its really difficult that we can see ICAI answer sheets

1. Good News although with reservations.

 

2. It seems that collective efforts of students have been noticed by the Institute where CCI members  played a vital role. 

 

3. When given such an opportunity; prepare more for improving standards of answers because now the Institute will take more care on allotting marks.

 

It seems now numbers of years experience of examiners will go away to certain extent and some CAs qualified with Ranks will be given an opportunity to examine the answersheets. 

 

4. The disucssion of Mr. Chopra is on right direction. Many students wish to go for job which is very unfortunate state for the profession. After 5-10 years of job; most of members forget about basics of various subjects which they studied in depth at the time of CA Final; it is my experience.

 

5. Coaching classes are good for guiding purpose only. It is my opinion that 15 lectures are sufficient to have a proper guide about a subject. I am not telling about completion of the whole syllabus of a subject. Even if subjects are fully covered by the coaching institutes which they claim; still students have to work hard to have a grip over the subjects. 

 

6.  More practical exposures are required to be given at the time of training than the focus on passing the examinations only.

 

what about pcc/ipcc answer sheets???

really its a good news,,, bt i think it is more important to show answer sheets at pcc/ipcc level, so that students can have a wild idea on the pattern of attempting answers at the final level.They will already b preparing themselves according to that , and i think that then there will b no space of deduction of marks of students atleast on the basis of weakness in attempting pattern. 

Good Step by the Insitute

hahaha :D lol... this is never going to happen in the future of icai... all these are just lollypops for students... m not a pessimist... so dont wori abt it... wen i read this for the first time i fell off my chair laughing... woohoo...ROFL







GUYS public exams are never meant to disclose answer sheets... its a world class standard & protocol to conduct public exams... go and check it out with any CFA, CPA, CIMA, CS, MBA or IAS any any any damn name...

I dont know how can people trust such funny announcements hehehe :P :P :P ;)...

What is the use even if they allow us to see the papers, big deal, we wont be able to challenge the marking system even if v r not satisfied with the marks they awarded......

ALLOWING US TO SEE THE PAPERS, NO WAY GUARENTEES THE MARKS ARE AWARDED PROPERLY AND THAT THEY CAN BE CHALLENGED!!!..I feel so..

Yes, I am fully agreeing with Revathy.

 

Instead let them upload the top 50 ranks papers after correction on the public domain of ICAI website for each exam. So that we can see what is the difference between our answer and best answers.

 

Also release the suggested answers before the results, so that students can at least make an advance assessment of the results.

 

This Copy of answersheet obsession is not good - it's like postmortem of dead body only. Dead person is not going to come back to life.

Very good news.........

yeah,heard so..tht's a good news.


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register